In an unheroic age, Putin, Trump and Netanyahu are sick parodies of great men

[Hume]

All three lie habitually, careless of honesty or honour. They exploit biased media, thrive off corrupt practices and employ bully pulpit rhetoric to get their way. Like ranting demagogues of old, Trump can skilfully rally a rabble. Netanyahu just shouts and threatens. Putin tends to smirk, snarl and snivel and hide when things go wrong, as in the region of Kursk right now.

In an unheroic age, Putin, Trump and Netanyahu are sick parodies of great men | Simon Tisdall

These successors to Stalin, Hitler and Mao are the ones making history in an unhappy, warring world

www.theguardian.com

 

[Hume]

​

Simon Tisdall

These successors to Stalin, Hitler and Mao are the ones making history in an unhappy, warring world
Sat 31 Aug 2024 12.00 EDT
Share


The 19th-century idea that great men – exceptionally talented, courageous, charismatic individuals – direct and change the course of history by the sheer force of their genius and personality is hard to shake. It has persisted despite the rise of egalitarian and Marxist social theory and the advent in the 1960s of EP Thompson’s levelling up school of “history from below”.

The Scottish philosopher Thomas Carlyle viewed figures such as Aristotle, Julius Caesar, Napoleon, Martin Luther and the prophet Muhammad as standout heroes of their time who fundamentally, permanently changed the world around them. The mass of mankind, he believed, could merely watch, marvel, admire and tamely follow these top-down makers and shakers of “universal history”.