signalmankenneth
Verified User
The supreme court is finally doing there job?!! I would say the democrat's will retake the house in November now?!!
Keep in mind there are a couple of more states waiting on the supreme court to rule on this same subject too?!!
CNN —
The Supreme Court paused a chaotic legal fight over Louisiana’s congressional districts in a brief order Wednesday that will likely allow the state to use a map in this year’s election that creates a second majority-Black district and benefits Democrats.
The court’s three liberal justices publicly dissented from the decision.
Louisiana specifically asked the Supreme Court last week to rely on a legal doctrine known as the Purcell principle, which it sometimes invokes to stay out of last-minute election lawsuits. The majority cited Purcell in its brief order but did not otherwise explain its reasoning.
But the court has never defined “last-minute” and it has faced blowback in recent years for applying that doctrine in a way critics see as inconsistent. Louisiana won’t hold its congressional primary election until November.
The ruling will have an impact beyond the Louisiana district, which explains the vote count, said CNN Supreme Court Analyst Steve Vladeck.
“This ruling is a short-term win for Black voters in Louisiana, and, thus, Democrats, but a long-term expansion of a deeply controversial approach to how federal courts handle election-year voting cases – which is a big part of why the justices seem to all have ended up in unpredictable positions here,” said Vladeck, a professor at the University of Texas School of Law.
In a brief separate opinion, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said it was premature for the Supreme Court to intervene in the case.
“Rather than wading in now, I would have let the District Court’s remedial process run its course before considering whether our emergency intervention was warranted,” Jackson wrote.
https://www.cnn.com/2024/05/15/politics/supreme-court-louisiana-black-voters-congressional-district/index.html
Keep in mind there are a couple of more states waiting on the supreme court to rule on this same subject too?!!
CNN —
The Supreme Court paused a chaotic legal fight over Louisiana’s congressional districts in a brief order Wednesday that will likely allow the state to use a map in this year’s election that creates a second majority-Black district and benefits Democrats.
The court’s three liberal justices publicly dissented from the decision.
Louisiana specifically asked the Supreme Court last week to rely on a legal doctrine known as the Purcell principle, which it sometimes invokes to stay out of last-minute election lawsuits. The majority cited Purcell in its brief order but did not otherwise explain its reasoning.
But the court has never defined “last-minute” and it has faced blowback in recent years for applying that doctrine in a way critics see as inconsistent. Louisiana won’t hold its congressional primary election until November.
The ruling will have an impact beyond the Louisiana district, which explains the vote count, said CNN Supreme Court Analyst Steve Vladeck.
“This ruling is a short-term win for Black voters in Louisiana, and, thus, Democrats, but a long-term expansion of a deeply controversial approach to how federal courts handle election-year voting cases – which is a big part of why the justices seem to all have ended up in unpredictable positions here,” said Vladeck, a professor at the University of Texas School of Law.
In a brief separate opinion, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said it was premature for the Supreme Court to intervene in the case.
“Rather than wading in now, I would have let the District Court’s remedial process run its course before considering whether our emergency intervention was warranted,” Jackson wrote.
https://www.cnn.com/2024/05/15/politics/supreme-court-louisiana-black-voters-congressional-district/index.html