There long dead
The electoral college was originally meant to convene and intelligently decide who was going to be president, since the founders thought there was no way that the ignorant masses could understand the nuances of a presidential election. However, within two they had the system rigged where they only voted for people who had expressly stated whom they would vote for. The founders underestimated the intelligence of the average American, and now all we have today is just a complicated system of distorting the popular vote, which doesn't make the election of bad candidates any less likely at all.
I think the 19th Century, which came on the death of the Federalists, is proof that the Founders were right about the people. I mean, Jackson over John Quincy Adams? WTF? And lets not forget when we elected that hottie JFK into office (granted, his opponent sucked too) in the last Century. No, the consistency of the public to be ignoramouses is unending.
I am a Democrat mainly because I hate what Republicans have done to my country since Regan.
But the people did outsmart the founders, Threedee.
Instead of electing people to make a rational decision, we elect people to make our rational decision. The founders didn't think it possible, but it happened almost instantly.
Desh, income, the stock market, economic growth, poverty, etc. might seem like they do better under democrats.
But, its all just business cycles. Or as superfreak might say: Democrats just get lucky. For the past 80 years. Quite a streak of luck, actually.