You make some good points but I don't agree with you completely. First of all, were all in this together and working together we can make good things happen.
First lets look at what the problem with unemployment is? The problem with unemployment is that the jobs situation in this nation has changed drastically. It's no longer labor oriented but skills oriented. We currently have about 5 million jobs in this nation that are going unfilled because there are not enough people with the skills to fill those positions. If we could fill those jobs that would drop unemployment down to a reasonable 5% (approx). We need to fix that, we need to find some way to increase the training and educational oppurtunities so that these jobs can be filled. The economic spin off from that alone would be substantial.
Yes, there is a problem with skills falling behind needs. But that has been a constant problem since industrialization. And while addressing the problem has great potential, it still leave us in a situation where too much employment is dependent on an unstable market. The more people who become self reliant for their income, the more stable the overall economy will become, which in turn will allow us the ability to put more into addressing other concerns WITHOUT adding to the already anchor-around-the-ankle-of-a-drowning-man national debt.
To do that several things need to happen. Those who are unemployed with old skill sets or from labor intensive jobs have to accept personal accountability in that they must do the work and make the sacrifices to learn new jobs skills that make them marketable again or at the least upgrade the skills they do have to make them more current.
To help these people a combination of public and private support would help. Now don't get me wrong, the individual needs to do the work to learn new skills but I see no problem with the government providing these people support as long as those being assisted demonstrate measurable progress in gaining education and new jobs skills. We should also provide incentives, such at tax cuts or exemptions, to industry/business for providing skills training to fill these positions internally. It would require a sizable investment but history has shown, using for example the GI Bill, that the return on investment would be huge. I see a lot to be gained from such a collaboration between individuals, the Government and Business/Industry to promote jobs and skills training and education. It's a win/win situation that can realize a huge return on investment.
Not bad. Just one question: how would unemployment benefits play into this? Do we modify requirements from the now pitiful "did you look for work this week?"
Another good idea is public works. That is an ivestment that usually pays off well too but if we really want something like that to succeed it has to be not only a very large national project but a forward thinking one. Some historical precedence that I would give in which such projects had immeasurable benefits, economic and otherwise, would be The Intercontinental Railroad, The Panama Canal and The Space Race/Manned Moon missions. I would be all for such a forward thinking national project. One that I can think of that has potential is a national project to have our nation energy dependent and off foreign oil by 2025. Say a national Manhattan project for energy independence. We can put a lot of people to work, create economic wealth and promote strategic and security goals that energy independence would provide.
I cannot fully agree with this. While public works is one of the better uses of our tax money, using such to build the economy ends up with a dependency on them, and that cannot be held up indefinitely. I do not object to the idea that government can work with industry to assist in problem areas like the gap between skills and job requirements, using public works as a means to grow the economy is the opposite of that - it is dependency on government itself to directly provide, not to mention that pesky deficit/national debt problem. That is the big mistake we have been making since turn of the last century. Public works should be viewed as more icing on the cake in a healthy economy. They should be fully paid for before they even start, and should not be viewed as an essential part of the economy.
So there's a lot to be said for individual effort and accountability and I'm all for it but it would be a big mistake to discount the positive role both government and business/industry can provide if all three sectors were to collaborate for this common goal.
I did not say we should simply turn our backs on government, or big business. They most obviously have their place. What I said was we need to quit
depending on them to solve our economic woes. As it sits right now, we have literally millions of people sitting around, dependent on government to assist them while they wait for big business to put them back to work. And while your proposal to create a system that helps close the skills gap is not without merit, in the end that is still another situation of the people depending on government to help them out while they wait for big business to provide them with a job.
Every time the economy goes in a slump, the focus is on government programs combined with tax breaks and outright corporate welfare to get things going again, while the people wait around for the various ideas to take hold. People need to start being more self sufficient instead of looking to someone else to solve their (and our) problems. We have become, way too much, a society of dependency. Dependency on government programs to provide us in times of need (programs which purposely KEEP way too many in need); and dependency on big business to provide our jobs. Either way, people are looking to others for their own well being. And the problem with that is the others they are looking to are only interested in securing more wealth and power for themselves at the expense of the people. If it helps provide people with an income, that is just a happy coincidence, and often all too temporary.
Our real strength in the past has been the people themselves providing for themselves. That has always been the real strength of a free society. With diminished use of that strength comes diminished freedom. But, it can once again become our real strength, if we but simply choose to use it. You mentioned trying to close the skills gap. If we are going to do that, why not include a focus on skills that would help people create and/or operate their own business?
One does not have to be an entrepreneur to make their own job. When is the last time you had to hire a plumber? Or an electrician? How easy is it to get one on a same day basis (without taking out a fifth mortgage)? I don't know about you, but I have to make an appointment a good week in advance if I need my mechanic. (With modern engines, gone are the days of the home mechanic!) The thing is, we are still, very much, a land of opportunity. But, it takes work, and personal responsibility, to take advantage of the opportunities out there. The problem with big government programs and big business solutions is they squelch personal responsibility in favor of waiting for someone else to fix things for us.