60 Minutes' Identifies 'Curve Ball'

uscitizen

Villified User
60 Minutes' Identifies 'Curve Ball' Source Who Led U.S. to Invade Iraq

Thursday, November 01, 2007

The identity of the man who claimed former Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein had biological weapons, a key piece of information that helped lead the U.S. charge to invade Iraq, has been outed by CBS' "60 Minutes" news show.

Rafid Ahmed Alwan, known as "Curve Ball" in intelligence circles, is not a chemical engineering expert, according to the report, which instead characterized Alwan as a liar, a thief and poor student.

The CIA received hundreds of summaries of debriefings with Alwan, contributing to other intelligence reports that led the United States to bomb and invade Iraq. Former CIA Director George Tenet gave Alwan's allegations to Secretary of State Colin Powell for his report to the United Nations in the argument to take military action against Iraq, the news magazine reports.

The two-year investigation undertaken found that Alwan arrived in a refugee camp in Germany in 1999 and claimed to be a chemical engineer leading a facility at Djerf al Nadaf that was making mobile biological weapons. The news magazine reports that Alwan was looking for asylum and used his claims to bolster his case.

Click here to read the CBS report.

Alwan did study chemical engineering but he received poor grades. The investigation also found an arrest warrant for theft for Alwan.

Alwan led officials to believe Saddam possessed biological weapons, telling German intelligence officials about his insight with mostly accurate descriptions of a plant outside Baghdad. He told officials 12 workers were killed by biological agents at the plant.

A letter addressed to Tenet from the head of German intelligence states that Alwan's information appeared to be believable, but there was nothing to back up his allegations.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,307479,00.html
 
The story of "Curve Ball" is one of Bush's most clear & blatant lies in the lead up to war.

He got a PDB a few days before the State of the Union speech on Curve Ball, totally discrediting the source. It stated that he was the only source they had regarding suspected mobile bio-weapons labs that were prominent the admin's case for war, and intel had revealed him to be an opportunist and not at all credible.

That didn't stop Bush from saying a few days later that "multiple sources" had "confirmed" the existence of mobile bio-weapons labs in Iraq.
 
standard Administration response:

"Hey! No one could have predicted that curveball's information was inaccurate"
 
This is why they like to water board and such. They can create the intell they want. All of the intell gathers already know torture gets you flawed intell.
 
Back
Top