Keep the Vigilante

[Mott the Hoople]

I say we keep the Vigilante roll permanent to Were Wolf. It adds a completely new element of strategy knowing that if you hit the wrong person (the vigilante) to hard for a response, you might get shot. That also slows down trains from being built.

 

[BRUTALITOPS]

wagons are a key element of the game. If you want the vig to get rid of wagons I would say you want the vig for the wrong reasons O_O

Vig also unbalances the game into villagers favor. (when used properly)

I like the vig. I also like the angel. I also like masons. I like trying differenet elements.

I dont think I would be in favor of it being a permanent fixture, it's really dependent on game size and stuff. a 9 person game with a vig is just wayyyy too unbalanced. But use vig again? I say yes. Just not every time.

 

[Mott the Hoople]

Can we kill Watermark instead?

 

[Minister of Truth]

SHOOT WATERMARK

 

[Damocles]

I liked the Vig because it really added to that best ever day one experience. I seriously couldn't keep up, every time I posted a new table three votes were cast and it was already obsolete.