APP - SCOTUS rules on FOIA and corporations and corporations as persons

[Schadenfreude]

has SCOTUS reversed an earlier decision that corporations are 'persons'


No personal privacy FOIA break for firms​

United Press International


The U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously Tuesday that corporations do not have a "personal privacy" exemption to the Freedom of Information Act. A statement after the ruling by rights advocate Public Citizen said, "The Supreme Court's decision is an important victory for government transparency."

FOIA requires federal agencies to make records and documents publicly available on request, subject to several exemptions in the law. One of those exemptions covers law enforcement records when the disclosure of those records "could reasonably be expected to constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy."

A trade association filed a FOIA request for records in a Federal Communications Commission investigation of alleged overbilling of the government by AT&T.

The FCC agreed that the records should be turned over, but a U.S. appeals court agreed with AT&T that the personal privacy exemption extends to corporations.

The appeals court said Congress in the past had defined "person" to include corporations.

The Supreme Court reversed. Writing for the entire court, Chief Justice John Roberts said corporations do not enjoy the personal privacy exemption under FOIA. Roberts conceded that in the legal sense, "person" often includes a corporation, but said the Supreme Court gives a term its ordinary definition when it is not defined in a statute such as FOIA.

Roberts said AT&T provided "scant support" for its definition of the statutory language.

Justice Elena Kagan, the court's newest member and former U.S. solicitor general, did not take part in the case.

A service of YellowBrix, Inc. .

 

[midcan5]

Interesting, maybe this court is not completely corporatist after all. One problem is you see the power of the lower courts and ideologues in complex issues that may not make it to the SCOTUS.

http://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2011...vacy-FOIA-break-for-firms/UPI-59331299003574/

"Corporate propaganda directed outwards, that is, to the public at large, has two main objectives: to identify the free enterprise system in popular consciousness with every cherished value, and to identify interventionist governments and strong unions (the only agencies capable of checking a complete domination of society by corporations) with tyranny, oppression and even subversion. The techniques used to achieve these results are variously called 'public relations', 'corporate communications' and 'economic education'." Alex Carey 'Taking the Risk out of Democracy' [see also http://mitworld.mit.edu/video/827 ]