considering that Obama has not dismantled the most controversial of Bush policies, does that make Bush a good president?
When you look at everything Obama is doing - from his budget, to domestic priorities, to foreign policy, to his response when confronted with crisis - his Presidency represents a 180 degree turn from the Bush years.
Bush was a very incompetent President, who reacted poorly to a variety of situations. He squandered the worldwide good will from 9/11, blew Katrina and was generally a patsy for PNAC and Cheney, among others. He was in way over his head, and never really fit for the job.