Why A Powerful Winter Storm Caused Blackouts In Texas

Cinnabar

Verified User
Coal, natural gas and nuclear plants ― not wind turbines ― were the main cause. But right-wing misinformation proved more reliable than the grid itself.

Republican lawmakers and right-wing pundits opposed to the Biden administration’s clean energy policies leaped at the chance to blame the Lone Star State’s burgeoning use of wind power for the outages.

But while the output from all sources of electricity plunged in Texas, frozen instruments at coal, nuclear and natural gas power plants, coupled with a limited supply of natural gas, were the main cause of the rolling blackouts, Dan Woodfin, a senior director for the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, told Bloomberg News on Tuesday. (ERCOT is the state’s main grid operator.)

Energy analysts and electricity experts said a complete failure to plan for extreme weather scenarios caused the kind of cascading disaster that risks becoming more common as climate chaos increases pressure on human systems.

Ironically, wind energy represented one bright spot for grid operators as the resource, which tends to ebb in the winter months, actually surpassed daily production forecasts over the past weekend.

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/texas-blackouts-wind-turbines_n_602c4e16c5b62767c0aaa263
If right wing profit motivated propaganda machine told the nitwits, pinheads and numbskulls to plant their mother on the roof for better TV reception, they'd all be running up ladders with their mothers slung over their shoulders.

Texas blackouts fuel false claims about renewable energy

“It’s really natural gas and coal and nuclear that are providing the bulk of the electricity and that’s the bulk of the cause of the blackouts,” Jacobson told The Associated Press.

ERCOT said on Tuesday that of the 45,000 total megawatts of power that were offline statewide, about 30,000 consisted of thermal sources — gas, coal and nuclear plants — and 16,000 came from renewable sources.

On top of that, while Texas has ramped up wind energy in recent years, the state still only relies on wind power for about 25% of its total electricity, according to ERCOT data.

The agency confirmed that wellhead freeze-offs and other issues curtailing supply in natural gas systems were primarily to blame for new outages on Tuesday, after severe winter weather caused failures across multiple fuel types in recent days.

Renewable energy is a popular scapegoat for new problems as more frequent extreme weather events strain infrastructure, according to Emily Grubert, an assistant professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Georgia Institute of Technology.

https://www.lmtonline.com/news/arti...uel-false-claims-about-renewable-15955589.php

Every opportunity these MOFO's get to stop progress they show up like a plague.
 
The extreme right relies on disinformation to survive, and this is the typical deflection tactic that the extreme right uses to conceal their blatant failures.
 
For The Thread:

I know many are frustrated at the lack of power or rolling blackouts going on throughout the state. One expert says, this is all Texas' fault.

This brutal cold that is hitting the entire state of Texas has our electric grid scrambling to keep up. Ed Hirs, is an energy expert at the University of Houston and he's said Texas' energy grid was doomed to fail at some point. He's been calling for changes since 2013 and now it looks like we waited too late to make those changes. This has forced people to live with no heat during a brutal cold.

Hirs said ERCOT, which acts like an air traffic controller and manages the power grid for 85% of Texas customers. It has no mechanism to penalize the companies that actually generate the power. Hirs said those generators typically focus their efforts on the summer months, when they expect their power plants to have high demand. Not in the winter.

“They leave them turned off,” he said. “They’re not winterized, there’s no antifreeze, they’re not oiled, they’re not staffed. They’re not ready to respond in a short term emergency like this.” He says these companies have no incentive to prepare a backup plan in case something happens like an arctic blast like this.

“The solution’s going to be to restructure the entire electricity market for Texas,” he said. “This has been a fool’s errand since it was passed into law 20 years ago. And it just totally needs to be revamped.” He goes onto say if you have been without power for a long period of time, you're victim to a broken system.
https://1063thebuzz.com/energy-expert-said-it-was-inevitable-that-texas-energy-grid-would-fail/
 
Excellent article in IER, here is your future if Biden gets his way!

About 60 percent of the homes in Texas are heated by electricity—most of which use resistance heating or the older kind of heat pumps that use resistance heating as a back-up when the heat pumps lag behind. A standard electric furnace or heat pump in this auxiliary mode pulls double the power that an air-conditioner pulls in the summer, which results in a spike in demand for electricity.

The electric grid manager, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, projects that demand will peak at around 72,000 megawatt hours during periods Monday and Tuesday, which is well above the previous winter record of 65,915 megawatts set on January 17, 2018. The state’s summertime record for peak demand was 74,820 megawatts.

Natural Gas Impact

Homes and businesses in Texas use electricity and natural gas for heat and over half of the state’s power plants use natural gas to generate electricity, which results in competition for natural gas between buildings and power plants. The competition has resulted in a huge increase in natural gas demand, driving natural gas prices into the triple digits from $2.77 in a normal week to over $140.

Gas processing plants across Texas were shutting as liquids freeze inside pipes, disrupting output as demand increases. Texas facilities operated by pipeline companies DCP Midstream LP and Targa Resources Corp. were reported shut on February 11 due to the cold, while Enbridge Inc. was limiting requests to transport gas on a pipeline stretching from Texas to New Jersey. Gas production in the mid-continent region is down 35 percent from the 30-day average. As much as half a million barrels or more a day of output in the Permian Basin of West Texas may be impacted by well shutdowns.

In Oklahoma, prices for gas delivered into the hub closed at $377.13 per million British thermal units on February 12. That compares with a $9 close on February 10. Prices began the week at less than $4.
On February 12, the Texas Railroad Commission issued an emergency order to manage the potential shortages of natural gas as residents try to stay warm and power plants try to meet electricity demand. The commission’s order requires that natural gas is delivered to residences, hospitals, schools, churches and other locations that meet human needs first, then to power plants and then to industrial users.

Wind Power’s Contribution

Western and northern areas of Texas have been coated by ice that has taken out large amounts of wind turbines. Wind farms across the state generate up to a combined 29,230 megawatts of energy. As of the morning of February 14, 2001, the iced turbines comprised 12,000 megawatts of Texas’ installed wind generation capacity. The wind turbines that have been coated in ice will need time to deice and warmer temperatures before they can operate again. When ice forms on a turbine, it weighs it down and can break it.

Wind power has been the fastest-growing source of energy in Texas’ power grid. In 2015, wind generation supplied 11 percent of Texas’ energy grid. Last year, it supplied 23 percent and overtook coal as the system’s second-largest source of energy after natural gas.

Rolling Blackouts and Customers Losing Power

The Department of Energy issued an emergency order allowing several Texas power plants to produce as much electricity as possible, which is expected to violate anti-pollution rules. The Energy Department order was requested by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas because millions of Texas households are suffering rolling blackouts for the first time in a decade as Texas cities are being plunged into darkness for an hour at a time—and in some cases longer.

Houston last saw a storm of this magnitude in February 2011, when rolling blackouts left residents in the cold and dark. The outages left thousands of area children in dark, cold classrooms as roughly 10 percent of the schools lost power for a couple of hours. At Hobby Airport, four partial blackouts temporarily dimmed some terminals but did not interfere with security or prevent flights from taking off or landing.

Texas grid operators were forced to call for immediate statewide conservation efforts, such as unplugging non-essential appliances, turning down residential heaters and minimize use of electric lighting.

As of Monday morning, February 15, 30,000 megawatts of power generation had been forced off the system. As of Tuesday, February 16, Texas had over 4.3 million customers without power, according to PowerOutage.us, which aggregates data from utilities across the country.

Conclusion

Cold, freezing temperatures have come to parts of the United States, and even to Texas, causing record energy demand and escalating energy prices despite Texas normally being a summer peaking state. Sixty percent of the state’s buildings use electricity for heating and the other 40 percent use natural gas. Since most of Texas’s electricity is generated by natural gas, the competition for natural gas has made natural gas prices spike as well. About 20 percent of the states’ generation comes from wind turbines, but half of them are iced up, putting more pressure on other sources of generation.

This is the future the United States can expect as President Biden works to make the U.S. electricity sector carbon free by 2035. In fact, it could get much worse as demand skyrockets to meet the needs of the all-electric car and truck fleet President Biden also wants. As the United States retires existing coal and nuclear plants, replacing them with wind and solar units that do not do well under icy conditions, Americans will be shivering in cold, dark homes and offices and reminisce about the days when fossil fuels and nuclear energy kept the power on. The Texas situation this week reminds us that energy is not something to be trifled with, as literally millions of lives are absolutely dependent upon it.


https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/the-grid/texas-plunges-into-electricity-crisis/
 
Last edited:
If right wing profit motivated propaganda machine told the nitwits, pinheads and numbskulls to plant their mother on the roof for better TV reception, they'd all be running up ladders with their mothers slung over their shoulders.



Every opportunity these MOFO's get to stop progress they show up like a plague.

The worst power grid I have ever experienced, was when I was living in Texas back in the 1990s.

And I have lived in a lot of places.

The power would sometimes go out if there was a strong gust of wind. And during one fairly mild winter storm, my power went out for two to three days.

That was unheard of anywhere else I ever lived.
 
Sounds like the democrats cuts to our energy production is actually killing people.

Instead of spending the money to ensure our power supply is healthy they are cutting maintenance costs which lowers rhe effectiveness of the machinery.

Anyone who dies from this was killed by liberals and their policies.

They have blood on their hands and it doesn't wash off.
 
Things are very very bad in Texas



First off this isn’t localized or even limited to big or even medium sized cities. There are rural areas that don’t have power either. This is a classic cascade failure. It is worse than a hurricane.

1. It started with ERCOT misprediction of energy demand by about 30%.

2. Sunday demand spiked to new historic winter levels. A full 10 MW higher than the previous Winter peak. Texas runs on electric heat. Virtually no one has fuel oil heaters. Fireplaces are things you have for ambiance.

3. Then it froze. The whole state in one night. That sounds not weird to most people but south of say San Antonio it hardly ever freezes. It barely ever snows. Like once every hundred years. But this was a deep freeze. Our normal once a decade freezes are it goes in the high twenties for a few hours overnight. This was a freeze that lasted two days. Lots of people just don’t have clothing to deal with this either.

4. So the roads shut down because of wrecks. We have trucks that the highway department can lay salt with or sand. But we had enough to cover those overnight type events on major bridges. Nothing like the ground freezing. People got stuck where they were. Freezing rain quickly washed the little salt and sand we had away.

5. Then the power went out. They said at first they would be rolling blackouts but when it went out it virtually never came back on. For my city the blackouts started around 2am Monday morning.

6. Since we never had a ground freeze they hastily told everyone to keep our taps dripping overnight so the pipes wouldn’t freeze. But we don’t have insulated piping. So many pipes froze and many burst.

7. Monday during the day the roads were still closed so you couldn’t get out. Heat was ok for many since houses could retain some heat.

8. Tuesday is when the shit hit the fan. Without power all the water infrastructure was hobbled. Pumps are non operable since entire sections of the city are blacked out.

9. With lines broken and pumps out and people dripping faucets water pressure has dropped to a trickle or none at all.

10. City orders a boil water notice because of this but large segments of people have no power to boil water with.

11. Meanwhile ERCOT tries to get everyone to start producing more power. Turns out energy production is as winterized as our houses. Gas power plants that had been told they wouldn’t be needed had gas lines freeze. Nuclear plants had instrumentation failures due to cold(a holy shit in it’s own right). Wind Turbines sited to provide surge power for Summer afternoons and built without heating elements had their gear casings freeze and lock up(they still outperformed ERCOT estimates). Even coal plants got knocked out with instrument failures. Roads being frozen means any maintenance response is limited.

12. So by Tuesday it’s clear any power restoration is a cold restart, meaning for instance you have to count on any re-energized building pulling it’s maximum demand. That’s because you’ve gone from trying to keep a building at 68-72 degrees to trying to get it from 35 degrees to anywhere warmer than that(our electric heat kits aren’t designed to do that anyway).

13. It did warm up enough Tuesday for people to drive. That meant firewood, water, propane, batteries of any kind, all gone instantly. Gas lines out in the street at gas stations. Dairy and meat shortages.

14. And cell reception is abysmal even for texting. With so many houses with power out people are using their cars to charge cell phones or stay warm. With so much internet traffic switching to cell based the network is slammed. It’s worse than New York after 9-11 slammed(I was there). Voice calls are impossible most of the time. Texts take 20-30 minutes to get through if they do. I think the battery backups and fuel tanks on back up generators are out on lots of the towers.

15. This afternoon was kind of the great migration when it became clear that ERCOTs promises that the blackouts would be getting rolled back got called out by the lines companies coming out publicly saying ERCOT was telling them to cut off more people. Think they got pissed people were rumor mongering that power was out because their lines were down. My fairly wealthy neighborhood is mostly abandoned as the neighbors stay with relatives with power or find hotel rooms. With cell coverage so bad it’s impossible to check up on everyone.

I’m only writing this because I have a natural gas backup generator in a brand new foam insulated house. I have heat, internet, and a working kitchen. I don’t have hot water because you have to make choices on what you can have hooked up and hot showers is not a priority when you have a Summer hurricane(It’s usually 100 outside after a storm).

I spent the day trying to get word to friends and neighbors they could come over and have a hot meal, charge devices, and warm up. Can’t get people to spend the night because they are worried about leaving pets and houses alone or are worried about COVID(We’ve had our first shots but not our second). I gave all my firewood to a neighbor who has a kid running a fever with a cough. I sent him home with hot coffee for his wife. I charged the phones and tablet of an ER nurse friend who hasn’t been home in two days because the road home is closed. Her partner is stuck there with her dog.

This has none of the hallmarks of a hurricane. In hurricanes you prep, the vulnerable evac, and it hits. It’s bad for a few hours and after that few hours everyone gets to work and things get incrementally better every hour. Help starts arriving from non impacted areas almost immediately. Lightly effected areas patch themselves up and send help to the epicenter in a day.

This shit just keeps getting worse. The closest “unaffected area” is 600 miles away.

So like Beto said on MSNBC it’s not as bad as the news reports say. It’s worse.


~ txjackalope
 
Excellent article in IER, here is your future if Biden gets his way!

About 60 percent of the homes in Texas are heated by electricity—most of which use resistance heating or the older kind of heat pumps that use resistance heating as a back-up when the heat pumps lag behind. A standard electric furnace or heat pump in this auxiliary mode pulls double the power that an air-conditioner pulls in the summer, which results in a spike in demand for electricity.

The electric grid manager, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, projects that demand will peak at around 72,000 megawatt hours during periods Monday and Tuesday, which is well above the previous winter record of 65,915 megawatts set on January 17, 2018. The state’s summertime record for peak demand was 74,820 megawatts.

Natural Gas Impact

Homes and businesses in Texas use electricity and natural gas for heat and over half of the state’s power plants use natural gas to generate electricity, which results in competition for natural gas between buildings and power plants. The competition has resulted in a huge increase in natural gas demand, driving natural gas prices into the triple digits from $2.77 in a normal week to over $140.

Gas processing plants across Texas were shutting as liquids freeze inside pipes, disrupting output as demand increases. Texas facilities operated by pipeline companies DCP Midstream LP and Targa Resources Corp. were reported shut on February 11 due to the cold, while Enbridge Inc. was limiting requests to transport gas on a pipeline stretching from Texas to New Jersey. Gas production in the mid-continent region is down 35 percent from the 30-day average. As much as half a million barrels or more a day of output in the Permian Basin of West Texas may be impacted by well shutdowns.

In Oklahoma, prices for gas delivered into the hub closed at $377.13 per million British thermal units on February 12. That compares with a $9 close on February 10. Prices began the week at less than $4.
On February 12, the Texas Railroad Commission issued an emergency order to manage the potential shortages of natural gas as residents try to stay warm and power plants try to meet electricity demand. The commission’s order requires that natural gas is delivered to residences, hospitals, schools, churches and other locations that meet human needs first, then to power plants and then to industrial users.

Wind Power’s Contribution

Western and northern areas of Texas have been coated by ice that has taken out large amounts of wind turbines. Wind farms across the state generate up to a combined 29,230 megawatts of energy. As of the morning of February 14, 2001, the iced turbines comprised 12,000 megawatts of Texas’ installed wind generation capacity. The wind turbines that have been coated in ice will need time to deice and warmer temperatures before they can operate again. When ice forms on a turbine, it weighs it down and can break it.

Wind power has been the fastest-growing source of energy in Texas’ power grid. In 2015, wind generation supplied 11 percent of Texas’ energy grid. Last year, it supplied 23 percent and overtook coal as the system’s second-largest source of energy after natural gas.

Rolling Blackouts and Customers Losing Power

The Department of Energy issued an emergency order allowing several Texas power plants to produce as much electricity as possible, which is expected to violate anti-pollution rules. The Energy Department order was requested by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas because millions of Texas households are suffering rolling blackouts for the first time in a decade as Texas cities are being plunged into darkness for an hour at a time—and in some cases longer.

Houston last saw a storm of this magnitude in February 2011, when rolling blackouts left residents in the cold and dark. The outages left thousands of area children in dark, cold classrooms as roughly 10 percent of the schools lost power for a couple of hours. At Hobby Airport, four partial blackouts temporarily dimmed some terminals but did not interfere with security or prevent flights from taking off or landing.

Texas grid operators were forced to call for immediate statewide conservation efforts, such as unplugging non-essential appliances, turning down residential heaters and minimize use of electric lighting.

As of Monday morning, February 15, 30,000 megawatts of power generation had been forced off the system. As of Tuesday, February 16, Texas had over 4.3 million customers without power, according to PowerOutage.us, which aggregates data from utilities across the country.

Conclusion

Cold, freezing temperatures have come to parts of the United States, and even to Texas, causing record energy demand and escalating energy prices despite Texas normally being a summer peaking state. Sixty percent of the state’s buildings use electricity for heating and the other 40 percent use natural gas. Since most of Texas’s electricity is generated by natural gas, the competition for natural gas has made natural gas prices spike as well. About 20 percent of the states’ generation comes from wind turbines, but half of them are iced up, putting more pressure on other sources of generation.

This is the future the United States can expect as President Biden works to make the U.S. electricity sector carbon free by 2035. In fact, it could get much worse as demand skyrockets to meet the needs of the all-electric car and truck fleet President Biden also wants. As the United States retires existing coal and nuclear plants, replacing them with wind and solar units that do not do well under icy conditions, Americans will be shivering in cold, dark homes and offices and reminisce about the days when fossil fuels and nuclear energy kept the power on. The Texas situation this week reminds us that energy is not something to be trifled with, as literally millions of lives are absolutely dependent upon it.


https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/the-grid/texas-plunges-into-electricity-crisis/

I’m not permitted to copy/paste that much text lol.

Good points though. The problem in TX is the same as in CA: too much mandated energy policy. If they are going to mandate Green stuff they should at least have an emergency contingency set up for extreme weather.

See lefties, it’s just that easy. If you want centralized control of everything at least do it with common sense and logic.
 
The worst power grid I have ever experienced, was when I was living in Texas back in the 1990s.

And I have lived in a lot of places.

The power would sometimes go out if there was a strong gust of wind. And during one fairly mild winter storm, my power went out for two to three days.

That was unheard of anywhere else I ever lived.

Cold shower time for ReTrumplicans, that is if the pipes aren't frozen.

120 all summer, -20 all winter. Cruz country.
 
Cold shower time for ReTrumplicans, that is if the pipes aren't frozen.

120 all summer, -20 all winter. Cruz country.

I would not wish this winter hellscape without heat or electricity on anyone.

Climate change denialism is a real thing though, and the gulf states are projected for the most extreme weather events of anywhere in the country.
 
Things are very very bad in Texas



First off this isn’t localized or even limited to big or even medium sized cities. There are rural areas that don’t have power either. This is a classic cascade failure. It is worse than a hurricane.

1. It started with ERCOT misprediction of energy demand by about 30%.

2. Sunday demand spiked to new historic winter levels. A full 10 MW higher than the previous Winter peak. Texas runs on electric heat. Virtually no one has fuel oil heaters. Fireplaces are things you have for ambiance.

3. Then it froze. The whole state in one night. That sounds not weird to most people but south of say San Antonio it hardly ever freezes. It barely ever snows. Like once every hundred years. But this was a deep freeze. Our normal once a decade freezes are it goes in the high twenties for a few hours overnight. This was a freeze that lasted two days. Lots of people just don’t have clothing to deal with this either.

4. So the roads shut down because of wrecks. We have trucks that the highway department can lay salt with or sand. But we had enough to cover those overnight type events on major bridges. Nothing like the ground freezing. People got stuck where they were. Freezing rain quickly washed the little salt and sand we had away.

5. Then the power went out. They said at first they would be rolling blackouts but when it went out it virtually never came back on. For my city the blackouts started around 2am Monday morning.

6. Since we never had a ground freeze they hastily told everyone to keep our taps dripping overnight so the pipes wouldn’t freeze. But we don’t have insulated piping. So many pipes froze and many burst.

7. Monday during the day the roads were still closed so you couldn’t get out. Heat was ok for many since houses could retain some heat.

8. Tuesday is when the shit hit the fan. Without power all the water infrastructure was hobbled. Pumps are non operable since entire sections of the city are blacked out.

9. With lines broken and pumps out and people dripping faucets water pressure has dropped to a trickle or none at all.

10. City orders a boil water notice because of this but large segments of people have no power to boil water with.

11. Meanwhile ERCOT tries to get everyone to start producing more power. Turns out energy production is as winterized as our houses. Gas power plants that had been told they wouldn’t be needed had gas lines freeze. Nuclear plants had instrumentation failures due to cold(a holy shit in it’s own right). Wind Turbines sited to provide surge power for Summer afternoons and built without heating elements had their gear casings freeze and lock up(they still outperformed ERCOT estimates). Even coal plants got knocked out with instrument failures. Roads being frozen means any maintenance response is limited.

12. So by Tuesday it’s clear any power restoration is a cold restart, meaning for instance you have to count on any re-energized building pulling it’s maximum demand. That’s because you’ve gone from trying to keep a building at 68-72 degrees to trying to get it from 35 degrees to anywhere warmer than that(our electric heat kits aren’t designed to do that anyway).

13. It did warm up enough Tuesday for people to drive. That meant firewood, water, propane, batteries of any kind, all gone instantly. Gas lines out in the street at gas stations. Dairy and meat shortages.

14. And cell reception is abysmal even for texting. With so many houses with power out people are using their cars to charge cell phones or stay warm. With so much internet traffic switching to cell based the network is slammed. It’s worse than New York after 9-11 slammed(I was there). Voice calls are impossible most of the time. Texts take 20-30 minutes to get through if they do. I think the battery backups and fuel tanks on back up generators are out on lots of the towers.

15. This afternoon was kind of the great migration when it became clear that ERCOTs promises that the blackouts would be getting rolled back got called out by the lines companies coming out publicly saying ERCOT was telling them to cut off more people. Think they got pissed people were rumor mongering that power was out because their lines were down. My fairly wealthy neighborhood is mostly abandoned as the neighbors stay with relatives with power or find hotel rooms. With cell coverage so bad it’s impossible to check up on everyone.

I’m only writing this because I have a natural gas backup generator in a brand new foam insulated house. I have heat, internet, and a working kitchen. I don’t have hot water because you have to make choices on what you can have hooked up and hot showers is not a priority when you have a Summer hurricane(It’s usually 100 outside after a storm).

I spent the day trying to get word to friends and neighbors they could come over and have a hot meal, charge devices, and warm up. Can’t get people to spend the night because they are worried about leaving pets and houses alone or are worried about COVID(We’ve had our first shots but not our second). I gave all my firewood to a neighbor who has a kid running a fever with a cough. I sent him home with hot coffee for his wife. I charged the phones and tablet of an ER nurse friend who hasn’t been home in two days because the road home is closed. Her partner is stuck there with her dog.

This has none of the hallmarks of a hurricane. In hurricanes you prep, the vulnerable evac, and it hits. It’s bad for a few hours and after that few hours everyone gets to work and things get incrementally better every hour. Help starts arriving from non impacted areas almost immediately. Lightly effected areas patch themselves up and send help to the epicenter in a day.

This shit just keeps getting worse. The closest “unaffected area” is 600 miles away.

So like Beto said on MSNBC it’s not as bad as the news reports say. It’s worse.


~ txjackalope

Where your link, Gonads?

https://m.dailykos.com/stories/2021/2/16/2016516/-Things-are-very-very-bad-in-Texas
 
Back
Top