All trans women are simply men pretending to be women.” Do you agree with her ?

[Yakuda]

I agree w/ her on bathrooms & sports & all of that stuff.

But this is really minimizing what some people go through. She loses me w/ that kind of characterization.

Why? They aren't fucking women!! They may FEEL like woman, they may THINK they're a woman and they may even LOOK like a woman but they are a fucking woman. What's the obstacle for you people? You aren't something else just because you feel think of even look like something else. How is this hard to grasp?

 

[Yakuda]

Nothing. Trans children are born that way. No pretending.

What way?

 

[AProudLefty]

Why? They aren't fucking women!! They may FEEL like woman, they may THINK they're a woman and they may even LOOK like a woman but they are a fucking woman. What's the obstacle for you people? You aren't something else just because you feel think of even look like something else. How is this hard to grasp?

Um we know their biological sexes. Easy to grasp.

 

[AProudLefty]

What way?

Transgender.

 

[Yakuda]

Um we know their biological sexes. Easy to grasp.

Right their gender. Got it. They aretn the other gender because they say so. You're born a man or a woman. So people are born intersex. That's not trans

 

[volsrocks]

What way?

So that one actress I can't think of her name right now she just so happens to have three trans children?

 

[AProudLefty]

Right their gender. Got it. They aretn the other gender because they say so.

Sex and gender are different. Gender is in the brain and an identification.

 

[Yakuda]

So that one actress I can't think of her name right now she just so happens to have three trans children?

Yeah of course because the probability of that is pretty fucking high. Doesn't everybody have three trans kids?

 

[volsrocks]

Sex and gender are different. Gender is in the brain and an identification.

So someone who identifies as a cat is really a cat

And a grown up 33 years old that identifies as a seven year old is really a 7 year old

 

[AProudLefty]

So that one actress I can't think of her name right now she just so happens to have three trans children?

Cynthia Nixon.

 

[AProudLefty]

So someone who identifies as a cat is really a cat

And a grown up 33 years old that identifies as a seven year old is really a 7 year old

Nope. Different species.

 

[volsrocks]

Nope. Different species.

Gender is a social construct" the roles, behaviors, identities, and expectations associated with being a man or a woman are shaped by society and culture, rather than reality

 

[Yakuda]

Nope. Different species.

Why does that matter? If you think its possible that a man is actually a woman because they THINK or FEEL that they are a woman then why cant they do the same with being a cat? Or do you mean to suggest that would be fucking insane?!

 

[AProudLefty]

Gender is a social construct" the roles, behaviors, identities, and expectations associated with being a man or a woman are shaped by society and culture

Correct.

 

[AProudLefty]

Why does that matter?

It doesn’t matter. If adults want to pretend to be animals, thats on them.

If you think its possible that a man is actually a woman because they THINK or FEEL that they are a woman then whu cant they do the same with being a cat? Or do you mean to suggest that would be fucking insane?!

Again, it's different species.

 

[domer76]

Why? They aren't fucking women!! They may FEEL like woman, they may THINK they're a woman and they may even LOOK like a woman but they are a fucking woman. What's the obstacle for you people? You aren't something else just because you feel think of even look like something else. How is this hard to grasp?

What’s with the obsession? Did your first girlfriend turn out to be trans? Or did they turn trans because of you?

 

[domer76]

So someone who identifies as a cat is really a cat

And a grown up 33 years old that identifies as a seven year old is really a 7 year old

LOL

And the desperate grasping at straws continues.

 

[Yakuda]

It doesn’t matter. If adults want to pretend to be animals, thats on them.

Again, it's different species.

Just like they can pretend to be a different gender. Thats in them.

Just repeating stupidity doesn't make it less stupid. What you're suggesting is the properties of biology can be altered by ones thoughts and emotions so they can actually become a different gender, then why not species? It's still biology. You want to draw an arbitrary line then suggest it's absolute? You're more fucking retarded than I imagined and I imagine you wearing a hockey helmet.

 

[volsrocks]

Correct.

The key word there is not reality...and made up by a society

 

[AProudLefty]

Just like they can pretend to be a different gender. Thats in them.

Just repeating stupidity doesn't make it less stupid. What you're suggesting is the properties of biology can be altered by ones thoughts and emotions so they can actually become a different gender they why not species? You want to draw an arbitrary line then suggest it's absolute? You're more fucking retarded than I imagined and I imagine you wearing a hockey helmet.

Nobody claimed that the biological sexes can be altered.

It's the gender identification.