Yea it’s one of those bizarre, irrational, circular logic, mind games academics play that know one else outside of academia really gives a shit about. The reasoning being that if your applying for grad school at the undergraduate school you graduated from something must be wrong with you if you couldn’t get accepted by another school.
Ya know I’m proud of the work I did as a grad student but it was 180 degree difference from my undergraduate experience and I came out of it with a low opinion of academics. Doing post grad research didn’t exactly improve that opinion. It’s like being a big brain on a squirrel cage.
It is considered a step up if you got to a school considered higher academically than the one you graduated from with an undergraduate degree. Makes you wonder where the kids graduating from an Ivy League school go for graduate work