Can anyone make a cogent case for how birthright citizenship is good for America?

You're flailing. Just admit your can't defend the plot by your party to colonize America using the third world.



I'm actually embarrassed at what a fool you have become. What happened to you? Oh right, Trump broke you - shattered you.
No way are you an American, comrade. With all this Russian propaganda it's pretty clear you're not from here.
 
Repeating your false claim of tens of millions doesn't make it true. It only shows you are committed to your lie and can't handle the truth.

Probably closer to 25 million under Obama's Biden Junta.

Your seditious party threw the border wide open in order to bring in millions of foreign invaders to colonize and occupy the nation. You are waging war against the Constitutional Republic. And you're losing - which won't work out well for you.
 
I see you decided to engage in ad homs and erect a straw man rather than support your claims.
Hmm.. So I provide a source (as you requested) showing that those born of immigrants are more likely to have good jobs and not live in poverty compared to other US citizens and you decide that is a straw man?
Pretty typical for the left - considering your positions are not defensible.

That is an ad hom because you are saying someone is wrong because of who they are.
 
What a retarded claim.

Again you duck the facts and fling shit.

{
The CBO estimated that by FY 2034, outlays for “benefits provided to immigrants in the surge population and their children” will total $177 billion. This includes:

  • $59 billion for Obamacare Premium Tax Credits
  • $43 billion for the EITC and CTC
  • $40 billion for Medicaid and CHIP
  • $15 billion for Food Stamps
  • $13 billion for child nutrition programs
  • $4 billion for SSI
The Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) estimates that federal expenditures on illegal aliens in 2023 totaled nearly $66.5 billion. This includes more than $23 billion in federal medical expenditures and $11.6 billion in welfare benefits from Food Stamps, child nutrition, SSI, and other programs.

The Manhattan Institute estimates that that every new illegal immigrant has an average net fiscal burden of about $130,000. The study finds that immigrants without a high school diploma who arrive in the U.S. between the ages of 18 and 24 – the profile “most commonly represented among immigrants who entered the country unlawfully,” – can receive $332,000 in taxpayer-provided benefits over their lifetime, including healthcare and other welfare program benefits. The report also details that “the border crisis is expected to cost $1.15 trillion over the lifetime of the new immigrants who entered the country unlawfully, overstayed a visa, or were paroled.”

The Center for Immigration Studies (CSIS) finds that the 1.1 million illegal aliens granted parole by the Biden-Harris Administration between January 2021 and February 2023 may become “qualified aliens” with a $3 billion per year cost in welfare benefits. An estimated 60% of illegal immigrant households currently use at least one welfare program, with an estimated $5,692 in federal benefits received annually. Some benefits, such as the EITC and CTC, provide an estimated $3.8 to $4.5 billion in outright cash payments to illegal immigrants.}



None of your sources address the children of undocumented persons. A child of an immigrant is a US citizen and by definition can not be an "illegal alien."
 
U.S. Citizens aren't deported.

ROFL - are you drunk?

Reminds me of the riddle, if a plane holding 50% Canadian and 50% American passengers crashes exactly on the border - where are the survivors buried?



Taking mass amounts of LSD and posting your hallucinations on a message board certainly sounds like a stupid idea - but you be you...
A US citizen can't be deported from the US to the country they are a citizen of since they are already in the US.
 
No one is deporting US citizens you fucking and total idiot.
Actually, there have been several instances of US citizens being deported to other countries because of "errors" by ICE.

We are discussing persons born in the US being US citizens. Since they are US citizens they are not supposed to be deported but you and people like you keep saying they need to be deported.
 
its amazing how simple minded you leftist idiots are.

Except this is EXACTLY the shit your Elon Musk preaches. It is something they all talk about. It's why your friends at the "Unite the Right" rally chanted against being "replaced".

They call it the "Great Replacement Theory". Check it out. It's fucked beyond fucked. And it's 100% your side of the aisle.

It has nothing to do with the color of people you daft donkey fucker.

Sure it does. It's why black kids have a tougher time being adopted in the US.


You retards say we need immigrants to do the work white people won't do.

We're seeing that in real time now as ag work is going un-done in parts of the Midwest

What you fuck sticks haven't ever explained is why this immigrants need to be illegal. Fucking idiot.

That wasn't the question, Dr. Fuckstick.
 
There is at minimum 10 million the last 4 years.

Bare fucking minimum best case estimate
Delusional claims are not reality.

This is from Congressional testimony in 2024.
We preliminarily estimate that the illegal immigrant population grew to 12.8 million by
October of 2023, up 2.6 million since January 2021, when the president took office. This
is the net increase in the illegal population based on monthly Census Bureau data, not the
number of new arrivals

There is no valid source that says that 10 million have arrived in the last 4 years.
 
Probably closer to 25 million under Obama's Biden Junta.

Your seditious party threw the border wide open in order to bring in millions of foreign invaders to colonize and occupy the nation. You are waging war against the Constitutional Republic. And you're losing - which won't work out well for you.
Your delusions are not reality.

Provide a source that shows 10 million have arrived in the last 5 years let alone 25 million.
ICE and CBP show less than 5 million in that time period.
 
None of your sources address the children of undocumented persons.

Why do you lie? Seriously?

A child of an immigrant is a US citizen and by definition can not be an "illegal alien."

The information is regarding illegals.

Oh, and you are wrong in your claim. In fact the SCOTUS ruled that Trump's EO holds - Anchor Babies are over - as is your plot to colonize America using third world peasants.

Your sedition has failed.
 
Back
Top