We can't use the same argument we always have? Because I said so?
I think you are comparing women to children, and I dislike that.
You misunderstand me. Beyond that children are full citizens. Citizenship becomes effective after either being born here or naturalized here. It has nothing to do with age.
Actually what I had in mind when I said this is having the drinking age be 21. So we aren't talking about children. So is this unconstitutional? Hmm. After your State's age of consent, probably so, but it saves so many of their lives I'm willing to live with it. I mean, when you consider that they can be drafted at 18 but can't drink until 21, that's outrageous on its face, but my preferred solution would be to up the draft age, rather than lower the drinking age.
And I don't deny that your argument has won thus far. But I am awaiting with interest the big one, and that is going to be the draft. You know full well we can no longer, with any sense of fairness at all, draft men and not women. I think most of us understand this. That's going to be challenged as soon as the draft is instituted again, and if you're paying attention, and I think you are, you can't deny that there is every chance this is going to happen within the next 2 years.
Darla I actually disagree with you about the draft. As foolish as this Admin appears to be I don't think they are that foolish. You can fully expect huge draft riots and civil disorder if a draft is instituted. People will not accept a draft to fight in Iran or Syria. The only way there could be a draft is if the government fabricated an attack against us like Pearl Harbor. Yes, exactly. That is the only way.
Plausible but not likely. We will see. I don't think we will have a draft too soon. We'll have to wait on that one. I will say that if the court does rule that women excluded from the draft is unconstitutional that would be revolutionary and I think the question I asked about age will be immediately asked. How will the justices respond. However they do it will be weak and I will be sure to be castigating them with the cliched term of activist judges.