To clarify, the original Dark Souls game had two ways of negating or avoiding taking damage. You could block it with your shield, or you could dodge the attack entirely. This allowed for several unique ways to play through the game. But then the subsequent games (Dark Souls 2, Bloodborne) completely disregarded blocking as a method of defense, making you need to dodge all attacks with rolling. This limits your ways to play through the game, and has subsequently become the butt of many jokes, such as what Watermark has done.