Because they are authorized to work in the US and therefore they are charged payroll taxes. They also contribute to Medicare as part of their taxes.
Elon Musk says Democrats gave 2.1 Million ‘Non-Citizens’ Social Security Numbers in 2024
- Thread starter Text Drivers are Killers
- Start date
Text Drivers are Killers
Joe Biden - "Time to put Trump in the bullseye."
HUH???? You stupid moron. You don't need an SSN to tax a foreign worker. Why would you.? Give them an FWN (foreign worker number) if you must . THINK
LurchAddams
There Can be Only One!
<sigh>. You understand that Elon lies his ass off. No, you don't. You're an idiot.No non-citizen should get an SS number. This is just more massive democrat corruption. Mexico and china paid Biden and pelosi and schumer millions to do thisl
Elon Musk Claims 2.1 Million 'Non-Citizens' Received SS Numbers in 2024
White House adviser and DOGE head Elon Musk has claimed that roughly 2.1 million "non-citizens" received social security numbers in 2024.www.breitbart.com
The disturbing part of this is that Musk was just such a resident alien, who worked in the USA, but was not a citizen. He had a Social Security number. He knows all this, and still he is lying about it.
Nah, you are conflating what he is saying. Folks are using these SSN to illegally vote is what he is saying. Being issued an SSN does not grant you a right to vote, you must be a citizen to vote in Federal elections.
Who using a Social Security number to vote? That is just nonsense.
Though it is what Elon is saying. He's said it on podcasts, and during the time he showed the chart that folks seem to be talking about.
Magats_Love_NHB
Let It Burn!
No, Elon Musk, millions of immigrants are not committing Social Security fraud
At a rally in Wisconsin, Elon Musk made false claims about extensive fraud at an agency that affects almost everyone: the Social Security Administration.
"This is a mind-blowing chart," Musk said, displaying a bar graph on a giant screen that showed millions of Social Security Numbers recently assigned to non-U.S. citizens.
The Social Security press office would not respond to requests from Scripps News to share the chart so that it could be authenticated.
Musk said, without providing evidence, that it showed undocumented immigrants were signing up for Social Security during the Biden administration to fraudulently obtain payments.
There is another explanation for why non-citizens are assigned Social Security Numbers, and it doesn't involve fraud. Documented immigrants who are authorized to work in the U.S. register for numbers so that, just like most everyone else who has a job, part of their paychecks can go toward Social Security disability and retirement programs.
"The employer needs that Social Security Number to withhold their money," said Evelyn Cruz, law professor at Arizona State University. "Just because you have a Social Security Number issued to you does not mean that you will eventually receive Social Security."
He is making up bullshit.
Though it is what Elon is saying. He's said it on podcasts, and during the time he showed the chart that folks seem to be talking about.
Althea
Althea told me...
You really are a moron. How do you think Bush got around non citizens picking crops? Immigrants pay billions into FICA every year, and will never reap the rewards.
Althea
Althea told me...
Been doing if since Bush. Musk knows that MAGA is simply too stupid to fact check him.
Honestly? I doubt Musk understands the issue.
And then you are making up bullsh*t about the bullsh*t? Super.
Instead of getting all bent out of shape over something he didn't say, start a thread about what he actually said... That way you aren't just the new drink of the random leftist: Misinformation Lite... It's less truthful, but it sounds great...
You may have seen the commercials: Less Truthful! Sounds Great! arguments cropping up everywhere...
Bullshit. They get around our laws as much as they can, then send money out of our economy to their relatives outside the US.
Arrest and deport everyone here illegally.
Nothing was conflated. The linked article makes no mention of voting. His intention appears to be to gull the uninformed, such as our poster, into believing the issuance of the SSN’s was induced by fraud. So it is Musk himself engaging in a kind of fraud.
Last edited:
Musk didn't write the article, someone that wanted to tell you what to think did. Rather than reporting what the man said they gave you their opinion of something he did not say. Yes, you, and the article, are conflating what the man said.
You're half right. He quoted, not conflated, a Musk underling.
ThatOwlWoman
Leftist Vermin
Wrong. My best friend from nursing school, who came from Ukraine and married a citizen, had one for years before she became a naturalized citizen. Ditto for her son, who was a teenager when they moved to the U.S. He also eventually became an American citizen while having a SS# before that. BTW he is now a pilot and a major in the USAF.
Ditto for another friend who came here from South Africa, like #PresidentMusk. She had a green card and a SS# for years before becoming a citizen. And ditto for one of our neighbors, a software engineer for Tesla, who also came from S. Africa.
What is the “half” that is wrong with his post?
ThatOwlWoman
Leftist Vermin
Because, Cletus, if they are legally employed here they must have one because their employer, by law, must deduct FICA and income taxes from their paycheck. And how would they do that w/o an SS#? There are literally hundreds of thousands of green card workers in the U.S. at any given time. They all have SSNs.
Texting Driver was actually able to come up with something that Musk said, you have just come up with things you think he said, with no explanation of how it could be true.And then you are making up bullsh*t about the bullsh*t? Super.
Instead of getting all bent out of shape over something he didn't say, start a thread about what he actually said... That way you aren't just the new drink of the random leftist: Misinformation Lite... It's less truthful, but it sounds great...
You may have seen the commercials: Less Truthful! Sounds Great! arguments cropping up everywhere...