Also, Dixie, you didn't address your apparent contradiction between "bringing the troops home", and establishing "permanent military bases in Iraq".
Depending on the day of the week, you've held both positions.
Then why did you mention Iraq being the second most holy Muslim land?
Because when you said you wanted permanent american military bases in Iraq, you need to be aware of how inflammatory that will be seen by many arabs. In particular, the shia.
The more inflamed the better! Let's go ahead and inflame as many radical nut jobs as we can, into joining the Jihad, as soon as possible! I'd rather get them all on board with their fanaticism right now, and take care of them in my generation instead of my grandchildren's. We should send out letters of encouragement to all potential alQaeda recruits, to go join the movement now... today... this second! Don't wait! We don't want to change your mind, we don't want to use diplomacy, we want you to sign up and commit yourself to blowing up innocent people in the name of Jihad, because this way, we can isolate and eliminate you from our midst, most efficiently.
al quada is in iraq because we are there. By that thinking it would be safe to say they are going to go whereever we are. iraq is as good a place as any to fight them.
i would add to dixies suggestion that they not only all join up with the jihadists but they should all go to iraq.
well if we just pull out and leave it as is... it would make AQ twice as strong as they are now, and make this so called recruitment tool twice as strong
The intelligence source quoted is probably a clinton hold over. Kinda like wilson was.
The cause for the increase in islamists is the liberal media and its portrail of what's going on in iraq. That and the stupid democrats. They do nothing but embolden the islamist at every turn.
well if we just pull out and leave it as is... it would make AQ twice as strong as they are now, and make this so called recruitment tool twice as strong
What on God's green earth are you talking about? Al Qaeda loves the fact that we're occupying Iraq, and they're still high-fiving each other about Bush's decision to invade and occupy.
A more prudent move, would be to redeploy our troops out of Iraq's civil war, and base them in Kurdistan, Kuwait, and Qatar. And from there, lauch air strikes and covert ops whenever an al qaeda threat is identified in Iraq.
BTW: that's exactly how we got Zarqawi.
I understand your position right up to the last paragraph then I have to disagree, I think that air strike was all a ruse. Doesn't it strike others as strange that they had the chance to take this guy alive and extract a lot of intelligence from him but instead they preferred to just go in and kill him, and then it turns out he was out walking around after the bombing attack and he died amost immediately after being strapped to the gurney. I think they caught al Zarqawi, tortured him until he was near death and decided to cover their asses by taking him back to the bomb site. There is no way he was in the path of that bomb and was then found walking around. That whole episode stinks in my book. But who's to question it, he was a dirty terrorist not worthy of a second look.
I think getting burned attempting to capture people and having them slip out tends to make people more likely to ensure an end than attempt a capture if capture is unlikely.Prak, honestly, I've seen no hard facts or evidence that there was any conspriacy to kill - rather than capture - zarqawi. No harm in speculating, but I tend to be more convinced by facts and evidence.
Zarqawi was a dirt bag, and good riddance. Capturing him would have been a plus, as you say.
And staying in there and killing people in Iraq is not making them stronger ?
AQ had no real presence in Iraq before we invaded......
Damn, they sure learned their way around fast! In any event, I fail to see the flaw in a strategy to draw alQaeda to the deserts of Iraq to die in a war they supposedly don't give a shit about. In fact, I think it's rather brilliant, if that is the case. Here, we have a terror organization spread out all over the world, and rather than us having to chase them down in every corner, they are coming to us voluntarily in Iraq! I think that is fantastic! And if there are any more rag-tag Iraqi dissidents out there, pissed off that their Saddam gravy train is up, I would encourage them to join alQaeda and let's take care of their heavenly virgin needs as well.
Let me be perfectly clear, I have had it with the leftist mamby-pamby rhetoric about creating more terrorists. As far as I am concerned, I want every fucking potential terrorist, who even has an inkling of an idea that they support Jihad, to come on out of the woodwork's now. If there is anyone out there that alQaeda can possibly convince, I want them to do so now. If you and your democrat liberals believe in them so much, you are welcome to go join the fucking Jihad as well, I want everyone who supports their ideology, recruited and ready to die for the cause... NOW! ASAP! I have no interest in trying to win their hearts or minds, I have no interest in trying to better understand their plight, and I had just as soon have them reveal themselves now, so we can deal with them and get it over.
Liberals answer seems to always be... RUN! HIDE! APOLOGIZE! Anything but FIGHT! You want to try to fight a PC war like a bunch of nitwits, and you are fighting with the politically corrupt, who will exploit you like the idiots you are, and laugh at you while they do it. So what if we cause more of the nut jobs to get worked up? It's not like the nut jobs are not going to eventually have to be dealt with, it's not like this can be all worked out with a little cash in the right place, there is no other option except to defeat the radical Islamofascists before they defeat us. Whether it's in Iraq or Afghanistan, whether it is pissing them off more or not... I don't really give a flying fuck.
Let's also be clear about this... There are 6 billion Muslims in the world, and the vast majority of them, do not condone or agree with the Islamofascists. This is not a war between religions at all, in fact, it is a historic opportunity for Muslims and Christians to unite in common good over common evil. It's also an opportunity for the rest of the civilized world to stand together in defiance of terrorism.