what is the "religion of science"? Just curious.
Here's what I think is happening: you last took a science class maybe in high school. You got an ok grade and now you think you know ALL ABOUT science and what makes good science and what makes bad science. YOU, who have zero understanding of the technical details of the scientific topics, think can call "balls and strikes" in that field.
May I ask you an HONEST QUESTION?
How would you feel if someone who had NO EXPERIENCE whatsoever walked up to you and proceeded to tell you how you are doing YOUR job wrong?
Answer seriously. It's important. Because you and I both know that you would RIGHTFULLY laugh in their face. So why do you think you can do that to someone else? Do you want people to laugh in your face?