The only reason I hoped for Trump over Hillary was SCOTUS nominees. He did well with Gorsuch. I'm relatively happy with that so far. If he gets more nominees into the court like Gorsuch I'll get more than I expected out of him.
I don't particularly like the way he rolled out the limited suspension of travel from countries that Prez. 44 listed as dangerous, nor have I ever supported the "build a wall and make Mexico pay for it" nonsense. Mexico isn't going to pay for that wall, especially if he pays for it with a tax on goods, only the people who buy the goods would be paying for that, and that would be US consumers...
On SCOTUS choices, I'd give an A. On the rest... I'm waiting to see what comes form the policy. I'm a results kind of person.