Hmmm. "Hypocrisy" has been thrown around. First, you have no idea that the guy runs around judging others and no reason to believe that he does. Secondly, his bible says that "all have sinned and fallen short". It doesn't say that this guy is the exception or that he must be perfect according to the 'Humanist Secularist Level of Judgment'...
I can't see why this guy wondering whether he should tell two girls he is dating about each other has any bearing on some "religious right hypocrisy".
I smell hypocrisy myself, but it seems to be coming from the "don't judge me without information" crowd, not the guy asking the moronic question.