How many sexes (or "genders") do humans have??

[gfm7175]

There is no contradiction.

Yes, there is.

If you met this person in real life, what gender would you think this person is?

I'm not able to answer this, as you have yet to clearly and unambiguously define what "gender" even is, in violation of rule #2.

Gender: what society assigns to individuals is NOT clear/unambiguous, and neither is Gender: what transgender identify themelves as. You have to do better than this in order for intelligent discussion about "gender" to occur.

RQAA.

Nope, you have not answered my questions. See my thread rules for more details.

There is no limit to the number of genders. And yes gender is a spectrum.

Perfect. We've finally made some headway! Now that we've established that "gender" (currently undefined, see rule #2) is a "spectrum", this leads us into rules #4 and #5...

#4: Clearly and unambiguously define "gender spectrum". IOW, please provide me with the left and right boundaries of "gender" for this "spectrum".

#5: Walk me through, step by step (I'm an idiot in need of education, remember?) how I would make use of this "gender spectrum" in order to determine where I would fall on it (How do I determine my gender?)

A person's gender can range from 100% male to 100% female. Not sure why that is hard for you to understand.

What is your gender?

 

[AProudLefty]

Yes, there is.

No there is not. You cannot explain where the contradiction is.

I'm not able to answer this

Just answer the question.

Nope, you have not answered my questions. See my thread rules for more details.

Yes I have. Reread my posts.

Perfect. We've finally made some headway! Now that we've established that "gender" (currently undefined, see rule #2) is a "spectrum", this leads us into rules #4 and #5...

#4: Clearly and unambiguously define "gender spectrum". IOW, please provide me with the left and right boundaries of "gender" for this "spectrum".

#5: Walk me through, step by step (I'm an idiot in need of education, remember?) how I would make use of this "gender spectrum" in order to determine where I would fall on it (How do I determine my gender?)

RQAA.

What is your gender?

100% male.

 

[gfm7175]

No there is not. You cannot explain where the contradiction is.

Already did.

Just answer the question.

I can't unless you define your terms. The ball is in your court atm.

Yes I have. Reread my posts.

No you haven't.

RQAA.

Nope, you have not answered them.

100% male.

Splendid. How did you come to this result? Please show your work.

 

[AProudLefty]

Already did.

Incorrect.

I can't unless you define your terms. The ball is in your court atm.

Answer the question. Is the woman in the picture female?

No you haven't.

Yes I have. Not my fault if you cannot see them.

Nope, you have not answered them.

Yes I have. Not my fault if you cannot understand the answers.

Splendid. How did you come to this result? Please show your work.

Because I identify as 100% male and I am biologically male?

 

[gfm7175]

Answer the question. Is the woman in the picture female?

That's not the question you asked. You need to define your terms. I can't answer a question about "gender" if you refuse to define what "gender" even is... The ball is in YOUR court...

Because I identify as 100% male

You stated earlier that "genders" are assigned by societies, NOT self-determined by each individual. Then you contradicted yourself and subsequently stated that "genders" are what transgender people identify themselves as. You have yet to clear this paradox. Are you now saying that you are transgender?

You are now denying your very own description of "gender", as you are now self-identifying your "gender" rather than accepting whatever "gender" society has assigned to you.

It is obvious to me that, at this point, you are just making shit up and are choosing to deny biology.

and I am biologically male?

So what?? According to your very own description of "gender", it has absolutely nothing to do with "sex" ("gender" is a completely different thing, according to you).


Once again, you refuse to take a definitive position on anything. Unless you choose to follow my thread rules and address my follow up questions, our dialogue has now come to a close since you are just making shit up and denying biology.

 

[AProudLefty]

That's not the question you asked. You need to define your terms. I can't answer a question about "gender" if you refuse to define what "gender" even is... The ball is in YOUR court...

I will not respond about this until you answer my question.

You stated earlier that "genders" are assigned by societies, NOT self-determined by each individual. Then you contradicted yourself and subsequently stated that "genders" are what transgender people identify themselves as. You have yet to clear this paradox. Are you now saying that you are transgender?

Correct. Societies define genders. Transgender people identify as genders defined by societies.

It is obvious to me that, at this point, you are just making shit up and are choosing to deny biology.

I never denied biology. Biological sexes are biological sexes. Nothing else.

So what?? According to your very own description of "gender", it has absolutely nothing to do with "sex" ("gender" is a completely different thing, according to you).

Correct. Biological sex and gender are different things and yet related.

Once again, you refuse to take a definitive position on anything. Unless you choose to follow my thread rules and address my follow up questions, our dialogue has now come to a close since you are just making shit up and denying biology.

Made what shit up?

I am still within the realm of biology and your so called rules. No clue why you have a problem with me following your rules?

 

[gfm7175]

... I am still within the realm of biology and your so called rules. No clue why you have a problem with me following your rules?

Continued ignoring of my thread rules and follow up questions.

Summarily dismissed.

 

[AProudLefty]

Continued ignoring of my thread rules and follow up questions.

Summarily dismissed.

Why are you not answering my question?

 

[AProudLefty]

Continued ignoring of my thread rules and follow up questions.

Summarily dismissed.

Well? Are you going to answer my question or not?

 

[AProudLefty]

Well? Are you going to answer my question or not?

Okay I will accept your withdrawal of the debate.