But but but, you had the pitching last year too and the Yankees still ended up with the ring. Say it with me, 28 in twenty-ten!
You're misremembering. Last year the Phillies rotation was a big question mark behind Cliff Lee. Hamels was not pitching all that well. Pedro was good but not by any means lights out and the fourth starter was Joe Blanton for crying out loud. THe Yanks had Sabathia, Pettitte, Chamberlain and Burnett. And we're not even discussing bullpens, including closers. The Yanks were favored to win the thing, not the Phillies.
This year is quite a different story altogether. Halladay, Oswalt and Hamels are all pitching extremely well and it is likely that the Phils won't have to use fourth starter at all throughout the playoffs.
In any event, I don't want to get too ahead of myself, Phils over the Reds in three, four at the most.