Dutch Uncle
* Tertia Optio * Defend the Constitution
No, but I've just added it to my Netflix que.Ever watched a documentary on Robert Crumb? That was creepy as hell.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0109508/
No, but I've just added it to my Netflix que.Ever watched a documentary on Robert Crumb? That was creepy as hell.
I loved his comics. They were as underground as you can go.
Few examples:
Heh at this one:
This one is one of the most popular characters:
This one has become a popular meme:
I recall his work, his style. The Keep-on-Trucking thing was big in Colorado when I was in HS and college.
I recall his work, his style. The Keep-on-Trucking thing was big in Colorado when I was in HS and college.
Being brain dead, a vegetable, obviously rules out any vestige of humanity.The question, really, is - even if your memory is wiped clean (tabula rasa), would you still be you?
Made me think of that movie, "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind".
Being brain dead, a vegetable, obviously rules out any vestige of humanity.
I would like to think human existence is more than just a collection of memories and experiences imprinted on the brain tissue.
That there is some agent or essence which owns those imprints on our neurological system.
But smarter people than me have been debating this for 2000 years, and I doubt there is a consensus opinon.
Being brain dead, a vegetable, obviously rules out any vestige of humanity.
I would like to think human existence is more than just a collection of memories and experiences imprinted on the brain tissue.
That there is some agent or essence which owns those imprints on our neurological system.
But smarter people than me have been debating this for 2000 years, and I doubt there is a consensus opinon.
The brain dead thing can be tricky. Is it dormant or dead, never to recover? Like you, I believe there's more to each of us than the sum of our parts. Something unmeasurable.
Going back to the teleporter scenario would the person going through exit in a vegetative state or a coma due to this unmeasurable trait? Let's call it a soul for lack of a better word. I don't know, but I do know both comas and vegetative states are not fully understood and that people have inexplicably awakened from them.
IMO, in most cases it's better to turn them loose, to pull the plug. There could be factors we don't understand. Do clones have "souls"? Yes,IMO. "Souls" grow when in a proper medium.
Since there's no evidence to prove any outcome, the subject will remain controversial for some time to come.I am on your side: once consciousness is permanently gone, I would want the plug pulled on me.
It really is remarkable how much human opinion varies of this issue more broadly
The Buddhist doctrine of impermanence maintains that they very idea of a "self" is an illusion; fleeting things like thoughts, feelings, and experiences are all that exist. The "self" is just a bundle of continuously changing mental states.
On the flipside, the Christian doctrine articulated by Saint Augustine is that we have free will and a unique independent essence Christians call a soul.
It is undoutedly a question thoughtful humans will think about as long as our species exists.
Since there's no evidence to prove any outcome, the subject will remain controversial for some time to come.
IMO, the next step of evolution is to become one with all. Becoming one with God is mentioned in the Bible and it's a tenet of Buddhism. Ergo, we lose our individual identity but become something greater like a drop of water into the ocean. The drop is still there, but it's become part of the ocean.
I always kind of liked the metaphysical Hindu doctrine of Brahman, which is the ultimate reality of the universe, pervasive and eternal, something in which everyone and everything participates in.
The question is, is who we are just the accumulation of experiences which have been imprinted on our minds/neurons, period, full stop? I believe that is what John Locke asserted.
Or are experiences something our independent consciousness owns, like clothes are to a human?
That is the 64 thousand dollar question.