What Phil Robertson DID do

[evince]

but only he gets a pass

 

[Ishmael Pequod]

but only he gets a pass

He did nothing wrong.

 

[evince]

so saying black people LIKE to be under the thumb of oppression better than they like freedom is fine with you?

 

[Ishmael Pequod]

so saying black people LIKE to be under the thumb of oppression better than they like freedom is fine with you?

That isn't what he said. You're too stupid and dishonest to continue with.

 

[evince]

tell us what the meaning of that little story he told was then

 

[Ishmael Pequod]

tell us what the meaning of that little story he told was then

Black people were better off before govt took over their care. The black family was stronger. He's right.

 

[kiki]

Black people were better off before govt took over their care. The black family was stronger. He's right.

Are you black?

 

[evince]

so you do agree that black people were better off when society held them to a certain PLACE huh?

 

[evince]

why is it black people disagree with your stance on them being second class citizens for their OWN GOOD?

 

[Ishmael Pequod]

Are you black?

When did you stop kicking dogs?

 

[Cancel 2016.2]

so saying black people LIKE to be under the thumb of oppression better than they like freedom is fine with you?

So lying about what other people said is fine with you?

 

[kiki]

When did you stop kicking dogs?

Did you feel that kick?

 

[Cancel 2016.2]

so you do agree that black people were better off when society held them to a certain PLACE huh?

Again... that is not what he said... YOU simply keep lying because you HATE the man for having different beliefs than you.

 

[Ishmael Pequod]

so you do agree that black people were better off when society held them to a certain PLACE huh?

Read it again.

 

[evince]

So lying about what other people said is fine with you?

then tell me what the meaning of that story was?

 

[Cancel 2016.2]

why is it black people disagree with your stance on them being second class citizens for their OWN GOOD?

Why do you profit off the backs of your tenants? Why do you steal money from them that could feed their families?

 

[evince]

where have I EVER said capitalism should be abolished?

 

[evince]

then tell me what the meaning of that story was?

you going to answer super duper?

 

[Cancel 2016.2]

then tell me what the meaning of that story was?

He stated that the black people HE WORKED WITH (not ALL black people everywhere) were happy, that they had strong families, that he feels they were better off without all the government handouts. Again... speaking of the black people HE WORKED WITH.

He said nothing about segregation or Jim Crowe laws. He did say that 'white trash' families were treated in a similar manner to blacks where he grew up. Again, anecdotal and not a reference to black people everywhere.

Now... are you going to stop lying about what he said?

 

[Cancel 2016.2]

you going to answer super duper?

Are you going to give people a chance to respond?