Why Isn't There a Palestinian State?

[Granule]

Native Americans are clearly far more entitled to the USA, than Ashkenazi Jews are to Israel.

Zionists typically aren't thinkers.

Leftists are virtually incapable of giving back. Why are you such assholes?

 

[BattleofHodow]

Leftists are virtually incapable of giving back. Why are you such assholes?

I'm not a Leftist, Zionism is primitive, and idiotic, not necesarily Left, or Right wing.

 

[Granule]

I'm not a Leftist, Zionism is primitive, and idiotic, not necesarily Left, or Right wing.

oh, but you are Left. Arguing to put Native Americans in control of this land is in direct conflict with the US and its borders. That is leading to treason, and that is very Left.

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

If people indigenous to the land are more entitled to the land.
Then certainly Native Americans are just as entitled to the USA, as Jews are to Palestine, if not much more so.

I think US courts should enforce all the treaties that we signed with Native American tribes in the past.

For example, Ashkenazis were gone far longer & mixed with White people.

That does not deprive them of their right to live in their indigenous homeland.

 

[BattleofHodow]

oh, but you are Left. Arguing to put Native Americans in control of this land is in direct conflict with the US and its borders. That is leading to treason, and that is very Left.

No, I don't support Native Americans overtaking other Americans.

Just like I don't support Jewish immigrants overtaking Palestinians.

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

Just like I don't support Jewish immigrants overtaking Palestinians.

Indigenous people aren't exactly immigrants.

 

[BattleofHodow]

Indigenous people aren't exactly immigrants.

I didn't realize the indigenous people of Israel / Palestine were White looking & spoke Yiddish mostly a German based language?

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

I didn't realize the indigenous people of Israel / Palestine were White looking & spoke Yiddish mostly a German based language?

All Jews are indigenous to the West Bank area.

 

[BattleofHodow]

All Jews are indigenous to the West Bank area.

So are Palestinians.

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

So are Palestinians.

If only the Palestinians were willing to peacefully share the land with their fellow indigenous peoples.

 

[BattleofHodow]

If only the Palestinians were willing to peacefully share the land with their fellow indigenous peoples.

How is Israel peacefully sharing the land with Palestinians?

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

How is Israel peacefully sharing the land with Palestinians?

Israel has repeatedly offered the Palestinians a two state solution if the Palestinians agree to peace.

 

[BattleofHodow]

Israel has repeatedly offered the Palestinians a two state solution if the Palestinians agree to peace.

Israel has never offered peace.

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

Israel has never offered peace.

Denial of Israel's peace offers is justification for deporting the Palestinians.

 

[BattleofHodow]

Denial of Israel's peace offers is justification for deporting the Palestinians.

Deporting Palestinians who have lived there for close to 1,300 years is an amoral disgrace.

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

Deporting Palestinians who have lived there for close to 1,300 years is an amoral disgrace.

Such deportations are justified by the denial of Israel's peace offers.

 

[Granule]

No, I don't support Native Americans overtaking other Americans.

Great. Then I trust you will shut the fuck up about this land belonging to Native Americans.

 

[BattleofHodow]

Great. Then I trust you will shut the fuck up about this land belonging to Native Americans.

Great, then I trust you will shut up about Palestine belonging to Israel.

 

[BattleofHodow]

Such deportations are justified by the denial of Israel's peace offers.

It's the Gazans who don't respect the peace, and as a result the West Bank must be deported?

It just proves Israelis just understand force.

 

[Anvil Kasseri]

It's the Gazans who don't respect the peace, and as a result the West Bank must be deported?
It just proves Israelis just understand force.

I don't speak for Israel. It really only proves that I just understand force.

But you raise an interesting point regarding the difference between Gaza and the West Bank.

Maybe Israel could reach a peace arrangement with West Bank Palestinians alone, and West Bank Palestinians could form one or more sovereign states separate from the Gaza Palestinians.