The Anti-Semitic Stench of Pink Floyd

Your claims here are only true if one forgets Israel's attack on the USS Liberty in which 34 crew members were killed during the 1967 war, and if you disregard the Israeli government spy Jonathan Pollard who was convicted and was handed a life sentence for spying on America for the Israeli government which awarded him citizenship while he rots in an American prison.


Israel apologized for the attack, saying that the USS Liberty had been attacked in error after being mistaken for an Egyptian ship. Both the Israeli and U.S. governments conducted inquiries and issued reports that concluded the attack was a mistake due to Israeli confusion about the ship's identity,[2] though others, including survivors of the attack, have rejected these conclusions and maintain that the attack was deliberate.[6]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Liberty_incident


Jonathon pollard was a US Intelligence Agent, he was convicted of giving information to Israel but was also thought to be selling information to other countries.
Id like to add we spy on israel and everyone else, wheres it written its only a one way street.
 
Let me get this straight. If one disagree with Israel and accuses it of doing some criminal activity thereofre, by default, it is considered anti-semitic?

Wow. What rock have you been under?

Those are the rules created by liberals back in the day when American Jews represented a voting bloc similar to the African Americans of today. It applied as recently as about 20 years ago, when Pat Buchanan criticized Israel and AIPAC and was lambasted in the mainstream liberal media as being anti-semitic.

I understand it that liberals dislike being held to their own rules, but there it is.
 
Wow. What rock have you been under?

Those are the rules created by liberals back in the day when American Jews represented a voting bloc similar to the African Americans of today. It applied as recently as about 20 years ago, when Pat Buchanan criticized Israel and AIPAC and was lambasted in the mainstream liberal media as being anti-semitic.

I understand it that liberals dislike being held to their own rules, but there it is.

You didn't answer my question....In fact, if you plan on going on a tangent at least you could define what the hell you mean. So let me ask you again, actually allow me to rephrase it: If I disagree with Israeli policies, and I believe that Israel is actually the antagonist in this situation (e.g the continuance of settlements even though the U.S cautioned against it) and I'm against Israel ultimately, am I anti-semitic?
 
Your claims here are only true if one forgets Israel's attack on the USS Liberty in which 34 crew members were killed during the 1967 war, and if you disregard the Israeli government spy Jonathan Pollard who was convicted and was handed a life sentence for spying on America for the Israeli government which awarded him citizenship while he rots in an American prison.

How many American lives has Israel cost? 3000+ on 9-11 alone. 220 marines killed by the truck bombing in Lebanon. The list extends infinitum, our losses in defending Israel in lives alone can't be counted when one takes into account all the death since 9-11. For what, an ancient claim to a chunk of rock that the other two sibling religions claims as well? All so Israel can rebuild the Temple and bring about the End of Days? The lunatics of this world are incomprehensible.

This one Yoda though is a particularly keen example of ignorance. Israel is own only friend in the world? Excuse me? Idiot alert.
 
Israel apologized for the attack, saying that the USS Liberty had been attacked in error after being mistaken for an Egyptian ship. Both the Israeli and U.S. governments conducted inquiries and issued reports that concluded the attack was a mistake due to Israeli confusion about the ship's identity,[2] though others, including survivors of the attack, have rejected these conclusions and maintain that the attack was deliberate.[6]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Liberty_incident


Jonathon pollard was a US Intelligence Agent, he was convicted of giving information to Israel but was also thought to be selling information to other countries.
Id like to add we spy on israel and everyone else, wheres it written its only a one way street.

I used to get very passionate about the Liberty and I was even a member of the Liberty forum where many of the people on board would post and take questions. They all said that Israel knew exactly what it was doing, it wasn't an accident or a mistake, it was deliberate. Liberty was under sustained attack for hours not minutes.
 
I disagree. I'm having big laughs, destroying your arguments. And to top it all off, managed to get MM banned.
 
You're going to love this about the author of the review, Rabbi Shmuley Boteach. He wrote a book entitled Kosher Sex and he teaches that women "are ENCOURAGED to wait out an abusive man to "prove" their loyalty." A few years ago he was on Dr. Phil and ripped apart a Jewish woman who was divorcing her abusive husband from an arranged marriage and then got shunned by the Hasidic community. A real piece of work, huh.

Both cut from the same cloth.

Using 50 words or less, please instruct us on how Roger Waters' diatribe translates to all liberals and the "Darlaks" in particular hating Jewry.

Refer to the rules of logic in your answer.


So what does this 'strawman' bullshit about the reviewer have to do with Waters being a Jew hating bigot ?

You pull this shit in a lot of threads....attack the messenger and forget all about the topic....

Are you trying to claim Waters didn't say what he said? Thats the point, not the Rabbi....
 
I disagree. I'm having big laughs, destroying your arguments. And to top it all off, managed to get MM banned.

You find me destroying your argument 50 times in one day funny? A little self deprecation is a good thing, I guess. How can you feel good about being continually proven wrong though?
 
So what does this 'strawman' bullshit about the reviewer have to do with Waters being a Jew hating bigot ?

You pull this shit in a lot of threads....attack the messenger and forget all about the topic....

Are you trying to claim Waters didn't say what he said? Thats the point, not the Rabbi....


What did Waters say that was in accurate, that should be the real question. Please prove which of Waters' assertions were wrong.
 
So what does this 'strawman' bullshit about the reviewer have to do with Waters being a Jew hating bigot ?

You pull this shit in a lot of threads....attack the messenger and forget all about the topic....

Are you trying to claim Waters didn't say what he said? Thats the point, not the Rabbi....

Obviously you didn't read the first sentence in the first post: "This will have the Jew-hating Darlaks running for their old copies of "Dark Side of the Moon."

But since you now put your dog into the fight, start by citing where any of the "Darlaks" stated they hate Jews, and we'll go from there.
 
I used to get very passionate about the Liberty and I was even a member of the Liberty forum where many of the people on board would post and take questions. They all said that Israel knew exactly what it was doing, it wasn't an accident or a mistake, it was deliberate. Liberty was under sustained attack for hours not minutes.

I can only go by the official versions, any incident has lots of personal opinions based on AIR and biasness. The official version by US investigators was that it was an error.

In my mind Israel isnt courageous or stupid enough to attack a US ship then or now, knowingly.
 
I can only go by the official versions, any incident has lots of personal opinions based on AIR and biasness. The official version by US investigators was that it was an error.

In my mind Israel isnt courageous or stupid enough to attack a US ship then or now, knowingly.

Well I am here to tell you that they deliberately targeted the ship and they didn't make a mistake. How exactly do you make a mistake over several hours anyway? I thought that when Obama got elected the first time the truth would finally see the light of day but that never happened.

http://www.veteranstoday.com/2012/06/07/alan-hart-israels-attack-on-the-uss-liberty-the-full-story/
 
Last edited:
Obviously you didn't read the first sentence in the first post: "This will have the Jew-hating Darlaks running for their old copies of "Dark Side of the Moon."

But since you now put your dog into the fight, start by citing where any of the "Darlaks" stated they hate Jews, and we'll go from there.

No, we won't start from there....we'll start with why you need to ridicule the Rabbi and ignore what the Jew hating bigot said.....

The Rabbi has nothing to do with this unless you're claiming he is lying about what Waters said....the Rabbi's views on marriage have nothing to do with the topic.
 
What did Waters say that was in accurate, that should be the real question. Please prove which of Waters' assertions were wrong.


What crap....if I say that more blacks are on welfare as their percentage of the population, I'm automatically called a bigot....whether what I claimed
is right of wrong is irrelevant to the pinheads.....if I say Obama is an socialist asshole, I'm called a racist, when the claim is obviously accurate....
 
Back
Top