At subsequent hearings in August and September 2019, an immigration judge agreed that he was deportable as charged (which Abrego Garcia also acknowledged) but then considered his three requests for relief. The judge denied the asylum request, because it could only be filed within a year after arriving in the U.S., a deadline which had long passed. He also denied the CAT request as lacking evidence.
But the judge granted Abrego Garcia’s request for withholding of removal, finding a “clear probability” that he would be persecuted in El Salvador. Withholding of removal is a sort of limbo status. It guarantees that the recipient cannot be deported to a specific country (in this case, El Salvador). But there is “no legal impediment” to the government deporting the recipient anywhere else at any time, as Abrego Garcia’s lawyers have acknowledged.3
The truth is not as tidy as either side would like you to believe.
www.wakeuptopolitics.com
Judge stated he could be deported just not to El Salvador ......but he could be deported at anytime to another country....Abrego Garcia’s lawyers have agreed this is the case
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTFOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLANDGreenbelt Division
So he had his due process in 2019 his lawyers agree there is “no legal impediment” to the government deporting him anywhere else at any time,...so his ass will be on his way to Uganda
Yes, in 2019, an immigration judge found sufficient evidence to conclude that Kilmar Abrego Garcia was an MS-13 gang member, a finding upheld on appeal, which was a basis for him being held in custody but also led to him being denied asylum.
Yes, in 2019, an immigration judge found sufficient evidence to conclude that Kilmar Abrego Garcia was an MS-13 gang member, a finding upheld on appeal, which was a basis for him being held in custody but also led to him being denied asylum.
It's a problem for the Left they can't solve. They glom onto some issue, take a position on it in alignment with their dogma, and then tenaciously defend that position even as it becomes more and more absurd.
The Resolution copper mine in Arizona is a perfect example of this in action currently. The Left is losing fight after fight to keep the mine from opening. They've tried the environmental route and lost. They got the usual handful of Native Americans--
This tiny group with maybe a couple dozen Native Americans from several tribes in it:
--to claim the land the mine is on is "sacred" and would violate their religious rights to pick acorns from emory oak trees that grow across Arizona. Their claim is only the ones right around the mine can do. When that collapsed in court, they got three women from the tribe to make an new lawsuit on the same basis. The women claim that--and I'm not making this up--that they need the religious right to collect acorns in a 5-gallon Home Depot bucket or two to make a flour after sifting the acorns through a sieve made from some rabbit fence duct taped to an old bicycle rim. They say the acorns are better than the ones they collect near their trailer park...
So, a handful of Native Americans making insanely specious claims about things being "sacred" (as usual) backed by a handful of radical Leftist environmentalists are fighting, and losing, a battle to keep what will be the world's largest copper mine from opening. They're delaying the inevitable because they cling to dogma like a religion.
It's a problem for the Left they can't solve. They glom onto some issue, take a position on it in alignment with their dogma, and then tenaciously defend that position even as it becomes more and more absurd.
I think the lefts establishment of civil rights, the womens' right to vote and voting rights are pretty good ideas and still are, if your cult would just let these things happen.
The Resolution copper mine in Arizona is a perfect example of this in action currently. The Left is losing fight after fight to keep the mine from opening. They've tried the environmental route and lost. They got the usual handful of Native Americans--
This tiny group with maybe a couple dozen Native Americans from several tribes in it:
--to claim the land the mine is on is "sacred" and would violate their religious rights to pick acorns from emory oak trees that grow across Arizona. Their claim is only the ones right around the mine can do. When that collapsed in court, they got three women from the tribe to make an new lawsuit on the same basis. The women claim that--and I'm not making this up--that they need the religious right to collect acorns in a 5-gallon Home Depot bucket or two to make a flour after sifting the acorns through a sieve made from some rabbit fence duct taped to an old bicycle rim. They say the acorns are better than the ones they collect near their trailer park...
So, a handful of Native Americans making insanely specious claims about things being "sacred" (as usual) backed by a handful of radical Leftist environmentalists are fighting, and losing, a battle to keep what will be the world's largest copper mine from opening. They're delaying the inevitable because they cling to dogma like a religion.
US Homeland Security, which says he'll "never go free on American soil", is expected to keep him detained for immigration reasons.
www.bbc.com
"The Trump administration said a Salvadoran man who was mistakenly deported and then brought back to the US on criminal charges will "never go free" on American soil, even though a judge ordered his release."
Starting on pg 8 you'll find a cover letter telling Garcia that the Immigration courts found him deportable and that he has 30 days to appeal the decision, dated to 2019.
Then what follows is Garcia appealed the finding he was an MS 13 gang member and that was ruled against letting that finding stand.
So, he had his hearing. Was found to be an MS 13 gang member and ordered deported. He appealed and the ruling was left to stand meaning he could be deported as an MS 13 gang member.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.