Dixie - In Memoriam
New member
I'll try once again. If the government is giving a person money, such as with welfare, what would be the point of giving them more so they could send some back?
For example, let's say a person earns $20,000. If one is permitted to deduct, say, $12,000 they would owe taxes on $8,000. ($20,000 - $12,000 = $8,000.) If a person is collecting $12,000 then they don't owe any tax.
Hold on a sec... point of giving them more? When the Feds raise my taxes, my boss doesn't pay me more. Why would we have to send them more? If a person earns $20k, he should be taxed the same as everyone else, you said so yourself. "All income should be taxed the same." ~Apple
Again... THE POINT.... that thing you continue to ask me for, and I continue to explain, hoping it might eventually penetrate your granite-like cranium, is so that those people who are benefiting the most from the system, are contributing something into the system. Now, if your argument is, they can't really afford to pay out money in taxes like the rest of us, perhaps the answer is to let them do some volunteer work, to earn their keep and have 'skin in the game'? (Biden's words) I would be willing to settle for that in lieu of taxation, if it makes you feel better. The thing I am currently opposed to, is a system where 48% pay no tax, and half of them are getting most of the benefits, while the rest of us are paying the tab. We can't continue to do this, we don't have enough income earners to support the welfare class.
I have always had this idea rolling around in my conservative head, that we could reform welfare, so that people who are getting gov't assistance, whether it's ADFC , WIC, SNAP, or housing, they would be required to give 40 hrs. of community service per month. That's less than two hours a day, so it wouldn't interfere with them finding work, going to school, or spending time with family, there would still be plenty of hours for all that. These volunteers could work in a variety of capacities, we could provide temporary day care for poor moms, or distribute meals to the elderly. Perhaps hospitals could get a few volunteers to offset the indigent care costs they are swallowing? All kinds of after school programs could be done, we have all kinds of facilities not being used.
Here is what such an idea would do... Three things... 1) It would virtually eliminate fraud, as there would be no motivation to steal benefits, because now "benefits" equal work. 2) It would weed out all but the truly needy, because most people aren't going to want to do the work for the benefits.... people will take ANYTHING that is FREE for the taking.... ALWAYS. 3) Those who ARE needy, and DO really need the help bad enough they are willing to do the community service, will have a sense of fulfillment, and pride, as they have now done their share and truly earned their benefits. Win-Win-Win!