So you apparently forgot that we don't live in a democracy. How disappointing. The Constitution doesn't include the words "democracy" or "democratic."
We live in a representative republic. Say it with me: " ... and to the republic for which it stands" The Constitution guarantees a republican form of government.
Say with me, since IBDaman is not mentioned in the constitutiion, IBdamann never existed. If you are capable of such specious logic, clearly, your credibility is zero.
"Democracy' is a descriptive term. It is a broad term. It is often used poetically. The documents don't use the term because the term 'Republic', is the even broader term, INCLUSIVE of democracy. It is also the more formal term. We are, in fact, a representative democracy, AND a 'constitutional republic.'. The ONLY time I've noticed you guys on the right arguing that "America is not a democracy' is when you guys stopped winning the popular vote, and now you cling to this notion in order ro feel good about it, because, after all, since y'all have lost the popular vote, well, you only won it twice in over 30 something years, you make this claim so you can feel okay about it.
In my entire 73 years, in and out of political institutions and the halls of educational institutions, academia, etc, NO: ONE, on the right or left, ever claimed "America is not a Democracy'. For hundreds of years, America is a Republic of a certain type. What is that type? A federal constitutional representative democracy. All of these terms are not mutually exclusive.
The term 'Republic' is the broadest term, includes both a government of appointed or elected leaders, as opposed to a monarchy, and ours are elected, both directly and indirectly (depending on the level of government).
So, I'll put it in more of an essay form:
The belief that "republic" and "democracy" are mutually exclusive terms reflects a misunderstanding of both historical and contemporary uses of these terms.
1. "Republic" and "Democracy" Are Not Mutually Exclusive
The assertion that the U.S. Constitution establishes a "republic and not a democracy" relies heavily on a narrow and historically specific interpretation of these terms, particularly as framed by James Madison in
Federalist No. 10. However, modern political science and historical scholarship clarify that a republic is a form of democracy, specifically a
representative democracy.
Encyclopedia Britannica Definition:
“Republic, form of government in which a state is ruled by representatives of the citizen body. Modern republics are founded on the idea that sovereignty rests with the people.” (Encyclopedia Britannica)
By this definition, the United States is both a republic
and a democracy. It is not a direct democracy, where citizens vote on every issue, but a representative democracy, where they elect officials to make decisions on their behalf.
2. Madison's Parochial Use of the Term 'Democracy'
In
Federalist No. 10, Madison used "democracy" to describe a
direct democracy, which he contrasted with a "republic." He argued that direct democracies were prone to instability and factionalism. However, this distinction is parochial and was
not universally accepted by his contemporaries (source, Encyclopedia Britannica
Democracy - Representation, Equality, Participation: Is democracy the most appropriate name for a large-scale representative system such as that of the early United States? At the end of the 18th century, the history of the terms whose literal meaning is “rule by the people”—democracy and...
www.britannica.com
Even among his contemporaries, Madison’s refusal to apply the term democracy to representative governments, even those based on broad electorates, was aberrant. )
Alexander Hamilton in Federalist No. 1:
“It has been frequently remarked that it seems to have been reserved to the people of this country, by their conduct and example, to decide the important question, whether societies of men are really capable or not of establishing good government from reflection and choice.”
Hamilton explicitly associates the U.S. experiment with
popular sovereignty, a hallmark of democracy.
Thomas Jefferson:
Jefferson, a contemporary of Madison, often used the terms "republic" and "democracy" interchangeably. In an 1816 letter, he wrote:
“The introduction of this new principle of representative democracy has rendered useless almost everything written before on the structure of government.”
Jefferson’s view reflects the broader understanding of "democracy" as compatible with republican principles.
3. The Electoral College Was Not Designed to Oppose Democracy
While the Electoral College is a feature of republicanism, it was not created to oppose democracy outright but rather to balance power between populous and less populous states. The framers were concerned about how to implement democratic principles across a large and diverse country—not about creating an anti-democratic system.
National Archives Description:
According to the National Archives:
"The Electoral College was established by the Founding Fathers as a compromise between election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote of qualified citizens." (archives.gov)
This underscores that the Electoral College is not inherently anti-democratic but reflects a pragmatic approach to republicanism in a federated system.
4. Republican and Democratic Elements in the Constitution
The Constitution includes both republican and democratic features:
- Democratic Elements:
- The House of Representatives is directly elected by the people.
- The principle of "one person, one vote" (later affirmed through amendments and Supreme Court rulings).
- Republican Elements:
- The Electoral College and Senate provide checks against potential tyranny of the majority.
5. Modern Consensus on "Democracy"
In contemporary political science, the term "democracy" encompasses representative democracies like the United States. Scholars reject the idea that republics and democracies are mutually exclusive:
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
"Representative democracy is often called a republican form of government because it is based on the idea of the public good (res publica)."
6. Conclusion: The U.S. Is a Republic and a Democracy
The belief that "republic" and "democracy" are mutually exclusive is an anachronistic interpretation. The framers debated terminology and concepts, but the government they designed combines republican and democratic elements, making the United States a
representative democracy.
The Electoral College, while controversial, reflects a compromise to implement democratic principles within a republican framework. Assertions that it was designed to "create a republic and not a democracy" are oversimplifications that ignore historical nuance and modern understanding.
In summary, IBdaMann, you and your ilk are full of shit.