4 ways to change the constitution.

Eagle-Eye said:
Au Contrair I only started in on you when you refused to accept any argument that wasn't exactly what you want to hear.
Click to expand...
Because your argument is incorrect, and repeating it over and over again does not magickally make it correct. The States (collectively) own the Constitution. They created it. They ratified it. They interpret it. They ratify any amendments to it. All Congress can do is propose amendments to the States for ratification.

Sources: Late 1700s History about the foundation of the USA. Articles V and VII of the US Constitution. Amendment X of the US Constitution.

Eagle-Eye said:
Considering I posted excerpts from Articale Vll proves you either don't read or ignore my posts.
Click to expand...
What excerpt of Article VII? I don't remember it ever being mentioned until I brought it up as a source. (I could be wrong though, and am open to being shown otherwise). I really don't think you've read the Constitution to be honest...

Eagle-Eye said:
If you have it's clear you don't understand what it says.
Click to expand...
I understand what it says. YOU are the one who doesn't. Inversion Fallacy.

Eagle-Eye said:
BTW I call you junior as my youngest son is almost twice your age.
Click to expand...
Yes, you have committed multiple logical fallacies with regard to my young 28 years of age, including but not limited to: Insult, Bigotry, and Bulverism.

Eagle-Eye said:
You clearly don't respect you betters or elders ( parental failure).
Click to expand...
My my have we gotten way off topic... Now you are criticizing me and my parents instead of discussing ways that the Constitution can be changed... You still haven't countered my argument at the beginning of this response.

Eagle-Eye said:
Sorry but the preamble says We the people not just the United States meaning the people are in control of state and federal government.
Click to expand...
Now you've become the latest citizen of Paradox City, Home of Irrationality... You argued earlier that the word States is not mentioned in the Preamble. Now you are arguing that the word States IS mentioned in the Preamble (but it also says "we the people")... Which is it?? You are now arguing irrationally.

Eagle-Eye said:
Again the people own the constitution. State and federal government answers only to the people.
Click to expand...
You do realize that States consist of people, right?

ARF. RAAA.
 
gfm7175 said:
Because your argument is incorrect, and repeating it over and over again does not magickally make it correct. The States (collectively) own the Constitution. They created it. They ratified it. They interpret it. They ratify any amendments to it. All Congress can do is propose amendments to the States for ratification.

Sources: Late 1700s History about the foundation of the USA. Articles V and VII of the US Constitution. Amendment X of the US Constitution.


What excerpt of Article VII? I don't remember it ever being mentioned until I brought it up as a source. (I could be wrong though, and am open to being shown otherwise). I really don't think you've read the Constitution to be honest...


I understand what it says. YOU are the one who doesn't. Inversion Fallacy.


Yes, you have committed multiple logical fallacies with regard to my young 28 years of age, including but not limited to: Insult, Bigotry, and Bulverism.


My my have we gotten way off topic... Now you are criticizing me and my parents instead of discussing ways that the Constitution can be changed... You still haven't countered my argument at the beginning of this response.


Now you've become the latest citizen of Paradox City, Home of Irrationality... You argued earlier that the word States is not mentioned in the Preamble. Now you are arguing that the word States IS mentioned in the Preamble?? Which one is it??


You do realize that States consist of people, right?

ARF. RAAA.
Click to expand...

Debating you is like debating lobotomized mule all fluff and no substance.
 
CFM said:
Yet they do. Do you know they got the authority?
Click to expand...
No they don't. SCOTUS has no such authority.

Article III of the US Constitution is quite clear about the role and powers of SCOTUS. Article VII is quite clear about who ratified (and owns) the US Constitution (the States, collectively). Amendment X is quite clear about who holds powers that were not given to the Federal Government.
 
Eagle-Eye said:
Debating you is like debating lobotomized mule all fluff and no substance.
Click to expand...
Ignoring the substance that I have provided does not make it go away. I will provide it for you once again.


** The States (collectively) own the Constitution. They created it. They ratified it. They interpret it. They ratify any amendments to it. All Congress can do is propose amendments to the States for ratification.

Sources: Late 1700s History about the foundation of the USA. Articles V and VII of the US Constitution. Amendment X of the US Constitution.

** What excerpt of Article VII did you post?

** You argued earlier that the word States is not mentioned in the Preamble. Now you are arguing that the word States IS mentioned in the Preamble (but it also says "we the people")... Which is it?? You are now arguing irrationally. You need to clear your paradox. Ignoring a paradox does not make it go away.
 
It appears as if Eagle-Eye (the OP) is running away from this discussion and his own thread... Ignoring arguments does not make those arguments go away.
 
gfm7175 said:
It appears as if Eagle-Eye (the OP) is running away from this discussion and his own thread... Ignoring arguments does not make those arguments go away.
Click to expand...

So it would appear. He has reduced himself to insulting people now. He has no more arguments to present.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top