OK then provide me a case about Indian citizenship that prove AI wrong.You are misrepresenting the argument. Indians that live off the reservation in property they own do pay taxes. Look up the Dawes Act of 1877 which granted land to Indians and made them citizens.
Dawes Act (1887)
EnlargeDownload Link Citation: An Act to Provide for the Allotment of Lands in Severalty to Indians on the Various Reservations (General Allotment Act or Dawes Act), Statutes at Large 24, 388-91, NADP Document A1887. View All Pages in the National Archives Catalog View Transcript Approved on...www.archives.gov
And every Indian born within the territorial limits of the United States to whom allotments shall have been made under the provisions of this act, or under any law or treaty, and every Indian born within the territorial limits of the United States who has voluntarily taken up, within said limits, his residence separate and apart from any tribe of Indians therein, and has adopted the habits of civilized life, is hereby declared to be a citizen of the United States, and is entitled to all the rights, privileges, and immunities of such citizens, whether said Indian has been or not, by birth or otherwise, a member of any tribe of Indians within the territorial limits of the United States without in any manner affecting the right of any such Indian to tribal or other property.
AI is not plenty for the internet since AI is often wrong. It doesn't verify facts. It only looks for how often something was said.
Activist Federal judge blocks Trump's birthright citizenship ban for all infants, testing lower court powers
- Thread starter Truth Detector
- Start date
Into the Night
Verified User
Annnnd you still don't know what 'jurisdiction' means.
The 14th amendment did apply to native Americans born outside the reservations that owned land that was taxed. (See the Dawes Act of 1877.)
If we go back to the Senate Judiciary report of 1870, we see the same thing expressed. Indians that paid taxes were citizens and subject to the jurisdiction of the US so their children were born citizens. Indians that lived on the reservations and had treaties with the US were not subject to the jurisdiction of the US.
In 1870, the Senate Judiciary committee was asked to address the question of whether the 14th amendment applied to Indians. The report says this:
From a perusal of these statutes it is manifest that Congress has
never regarded the Indian tribes as subject to the municipal jurisdiction
of the United States.
[snip]
In the opinion of your committee, the Constitution and the treaties,
acts of Congress, and judicial decisions above referred to, all speak the
same language upon this subject, and all point to the conclusion that
the Indians, in tribal condition, have never been subject to the jurisdic-
tion of the United States in the sense in which the term jurisdiction is .
employed in the fourteenth amendment . to the Constitution. The Gov-
ernment has asserted a political supremacy over the Indians, and the
treaties and laws quoted from present these tribes as "domestic, de-
pendent nations," separated from the States of the Union within whose
limits they are located, and exempt from the operation of State laws;
RQAA
I just did. The fact that you completely ignored the Dawes Act says what about you? This is from 1877 and 1877 is prior to 1924.
And every Indian born within the territorial limits of the United States to whom allotments shall have been made under the provisions of this act, or under any law or treaty, and every Indian born within the territorial limits of the United States who has voluntarily taken up, within said limits, his residence separate and apart from any tribe of Indians therein, and has adopted the habits of civilized life, is hereby declared to be a citizen of the United States, and is entitled to all the rights, privileges, and immunities of such citizens, whether said Indian has been or not, by birth or otherwise, a member of any tribe of Indians within the territorial limits of the United States without in any manner affecting the right of any such Indian to tribal or other property.
Into the Night
Verified User
Indians are citizens of their tribe, their confederation (if they have one), and of the United States.
They are NOT citizens of the State the tribe or confederation happens to be located in.
Their jurisdiction is their tribe and their confederation (if they have one) and of the United States.
Illegal aliens cannot vote (legally), so they have no representation in the United States and are not to be counted as a 'person' in the census.
Into the Night
Verified User
Indians are subject to State laws while visiting in a State. Reservations are federal land and are not part of any State.
Into the Night
Verified User
You just nullified your own argument.
Into the Night
Verified User
The 14th amendment does not apply to Indians. It applies to the federal government (part of it also applies to State governments).
In Panama, you can even be born on a Panamanian flagged ship to be born Panamanian.
Visa Falcon - Travel Tips & Visa Guides
Discover up-to-date travel tips, visa requirements, and destination guides to make your global adventures smoother, smarter, and stress-free—wherever you go.visafalcon.com
Panama!!! Yep, they're breaking down the doors to get into that country aren't they halfwit.
All persons born in Canada become Canadian citizens at birth.
Does Canada Give Citizenship By Birth?
ADVERTISEMENT The concept of jus soli, or citizenship by birth, has been around for centuries. The basic premise is that if you are born on the territory of a country, you are automatically a citizen of that country. Many countries adopt this rule and Canada is one of those countries you will...adayincanada.com
WRONG!
- Exceptions to Automatic Citizenship: There are a few exceptions to automatic birthright citizenship in Canada. For example, if a child is born to foreign diplomats or representatives of a foreign government, they are not eligible for Canadian citizenship under birthright principles. Additionally, if one or both parents are in Canada as tourists or temporary residents, and they do not have a permanent resident status, the child may not acquire automatic Canadian citizenship.
Canadian Birthright Citizenship: Understanding the Law and Seeking Legal Guidance - Falcon Law PC
Introduction: Canadian birthright citizenship is a concept that grants automatic citizenship to individuals born in Canada, regardless of their parents’ immigration status. While birthright citizenship is generally straightforward, certain circumstances and complexities may arise that require...
falconlawyers.ca
You're such a dumb fuck. No wonder you voted for Kamala.
I'm betting that you'll find some misinformation web site to tell you what you want to hear as you did above, dumb fuck.
I see you still want to remove any doubt what a low IQ, uninformed dumb fuck you are.
STRAWMAN ARGUMENT. We don't argue strawmen you brainless halfwit.
The only thing you are showing is what a brainless ignoramus you are. Panama?
I find it more interesting that low IQ, uneducated dotards like you think the Constitution grants birthright citizenship.
Doesn't know he is the biggest idiot.
WRONG again dumb fuck. That is up to the Constitution and the legislature. States do not have jurisdiction over our borders or foreign policy.
If you had a brain and an education, you would know this. Nothing says moron louder than a smarmy dumb fuck.
Pointless off topic blather.
Your the idiot that claimed There is no nation in the world that gives visitors babies automatic citizenship.Panama!!! Yep, they're breaking down the doors to get into that country aren't they halfwit.
WRONG!
- Exceptions to Automatic Citizenship: There are a few exceptions to automatic birthright citizenship in Canada. For example, if a child is born to foreign diplomats or representatives of a foreign government, they are not eligible for Canadian citizenship under birthright principles. Additionally, if one or both parents are in Canada as tourists or temporary residents, and they do not have a permanent resident status, the child may not acquire automatic Canadian citizenship.
Canadian Birthright Citizenship: Understanding the Law and Seeking Legal Guidance - Falcon Law PC
Introduction: Canadian birthright citizenship is a concept that grants automatic citizenship to individuals born in Canada, regardless of their parents’ immigration status. While birthright citizenship is generally straightforward, certain circumstances and complexities may arise that require...
You're such a dumb fuck. No wonder you voted for Kamala.
I'm betting that you'll find some misinformation web site to tell you what you want to hear as you did above, dumb fuck.
Is Panama a country? Yes/no
Does Panama have birthright citizenship that makes the babies of visitors citizens? Yes/No
Is your claim that There is no nation in the world that gives visitors babies automatic citizenship true? Yes/No
And why was the Dawes act even needed. You sure are dumb. If the 14th applied to Native Americans there would be no need for the Dawes Act or the Snyder Act. And paying taxes would have ZERO affect on whether or not a person was a citizen or not.
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
Have you noticed how since the Supreme Court smacked down district courts making nationwide injunctions at the drop of a hat that these rulings have largely disappeared from the news? That sure took the wind out of the Left's sails.
And that has ZERO effect on US law so what difference does it make really? Get back to the real issues at hand.