All trans women are simply men pretending to be women.” Do you agree with her ?

[FastLane]

Extremely rare.

This is like saying that because a baby was born without an arm that means that arms are now on a spectrum. It really doesn't change that humans have two arms. Fingers aren't really on a spectrum either even though some folks have fewer or more than ten (counting thumbs).

(The six fingered man... My name is Inigo Montoya,... You kill my father, prepare to die!")

 

[AProudLefty]

There is no evidence that transgenderism is based in genetics, there are wishful studies that found "many" different things they believe "could contribute" but they had to be factored with environment and how they were treated, etc.

There are MRI studies. Even some posters here agree that there are differences between male and female brains. That's based in genetics.

How did you think trans children start to exhibit behavior as early as say 3?

I am not arguing against transgender people. I am just saying comparing them to intersexual folks and using those rare instances with direct genetic links in a comparison to transgender folks which have no direct genetic link only "multi-factorial" (these possible genetic things coupled with other environmental and societal factors could possibly) relation is not a good comparison.

I understand. You think there is no comparison other than how rare it is.

How do intersex people identify as?

 

[Damocles]

There are MRI studies. Even some posters here agree that there are differences between male and female brains. That's based in genetics.

How did you think trans children start to exhibit behavior as early as say 3?

I understand. You think there is no comparison other than how rare it is.

How do intersex people identify as?

However they want to identify. Just as, in my opinion a expressed earlier, any adult can without such genetic twists. Rendering their existence moot in this discussion really. These things, though dealing with sex, do not compare to each other as they are not the same issues.

The correlation of sex within the topics do not make the topics the same in reality.