Costs tax payers $300 billion to raise minimum wage...thank you REPUBLICANS

Care4all

Junior Member
Contributor
House vote raises minimum wage By Richard Cowan and Donna Smith
19 minutes ago



The House of Representatives voted on Saturday to give some of the lowest-paid American workers their first raise in nearly a decade, while also handing a big tax cut to some of the wealthiest.

The House in the early hours voted 230-180 to raise the $5.15-per-hour minimum wage in three 70-cent steps until it reaches $7.25 in mid-2009.

During a bitter floor debate, Rep. Phil English, a Pennsylvania Republican, said most Democrats' opposition to the bill showed "they've always liked the politics of the minimum wage and cared little for the policy of the minimum wage."

But Democrats shot back that Republicans had staged an election-year stunt to get a minimum wage vote knowing the Senate won't go along because of opposition there to the estate tax cut. And some senators are opposed to any minimum wage hike.

Before this election year, Rep. George Miller (news, bio, voting record), a California Democrat said, "You never raised a finger to help these individuals" getting paid the minimum wage.

Coming shortly before the House was to start a five-week summer break that will give members time to campaign for re-election, the legislation also would cut estate taxes, derided by Republicans as a "death tax," and extend several other popular tax cuts. Its estimated cost was about $310 billion over 10 years.

The package is likely to be debated next week in the Senate, where its fate was unclear. Efforts to roll back estate taxes failed in the Senate in June. Such a cut is a high priority for Republican leaders ahead of the November congressional elections when Democrats hope to make big gains.

REPEATED REJECTION

Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid of Nevada noted the Senate has "rejected fiscally irresponsible estate tax giveaways before and will reject them again."

The estate tax cut is estimated to help less than 1 percent of American families at a time of skyrocketing federal debt.

"Workers at the lowest end of the scale are being held hostage to 7,500 families," said Rep. Steny Hoyer (news, bio, voting record) of Maryland, the second-ranking Democrat in the House, who wanted a minimum wage increase bill without the estate tax cut.

Those 7,500 families are the number of wealthy families that would benefit from the estate tax cut. By contrast, some seven million workers would benefit from the increase in the minimum wage.

Republicans argue cutting estate taxes helps small businesses and farmers.

The bill also would renew for two years expired tax breaks for education, research, college tuition and other popular items.

For several years, Republicans controlling Congress have blocked an increase in the minimum wage, claiming it would backfire by causing employers to hire fewer entry-level workers.

But Democrats stepped up pressure this year for the increase, arguing high gasoline and heating prices were making it harder for the working poor to survive while working at wages frozen since 1997.

They were joined by dozens of moderate Republicans in the House who, facing tough re-elections in November, challenged their leaders and demanded a minimum wage vote before breaking for the summer.

Recent polls have shown broad discontent with the Republican-led House and Senate. Democrats, hoping to win control of Congress, have tried to portray an out-of-touch Republican Party that has agreed to nearly $35,000 in pay raises for members of Congress over the past decade while refusing to increase the pay for low-wage jobs.

White House spokesman Tony Snow, asked about President George W. Bush's position on the minimum wage, told reporters on Friday, "We are for minimum wage increases if they do not jeopardize the ability of small businesses to create jobs."



Copyright © 2006 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon.


Copyright © 2006 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Questions or Comments
Privacy Policy -Terms of Service - Copyright/IP Policy - Ad Feedback
 
toby2 said:
I hate to see that mim wage bill get passed. Maybe it will be stopped in the Senate.


IT is DEAD in its tracks already....thanks to the lovely and pure and moral and honest Republicans we have in office! :(
 
the stupity of the Tobes is still intact.

The R party wont be happy until American minimum wage is on par with sweat shops.
 
Desh said:
the stupity of the Tobes is still intact.

The R party wont be happy until American minimum wage is on par with sweat shops.


It's already near on par with sweat shops....
 
They reduce issues to simplistic one line thoughts for the mentally impaired ,You know republicans.
 
O lobve the lying right spirit , they love to change their names to try and avoid the asshole thingss they have said in the past
 
The goverment should not dictate what a business pays its employees. But the min wage is just a feel good thing anyway. Only fools, children and slackers earn min wage. If you work hard, show up on time, do your job you will make much more than min wage.
 
Don't have at my fingertips desh, but why don't you get a newspaper and look in the help wanted sections and see what the local McD's starting rate is! LOL
 
And note even at that rate, they say you get a raise in 30 days. It is implied that you have to come to work and do your job everyday scheduled. But even IF they started at min wage, in 30 days they would be beyond that.
 
toby2 said:
The goverment should not dictate what a business pays its employees. But the min wage is just a feel good thing anyway. Only fools, children and slackers earn min wage. If you work hard, show up on time, do your job you will make much more than min wage.


That's a LIE, toby and I have posted statistics to this SEVERAL times over....

The MAJORITY of minimum wage earners are ADULTS, NOT children....

And even if they were children, why should they make less than the children of 20 years ago making minimum wage? Why shouldn't they be able to BUY what someone 10 years ago could BUY with their hourly minimum wage?

The Economy would DO MUCH BETTER if they RAISED minimum wage.....the states that have raised their minimum wage well above minimum are the states that have BETTER economies is what I just read...

so, please, please please stop with the lies and bullshit and rhetoric!

care
 
Comparing the minimum wage proposals
A new poll by the nonpartisan Pew Research Center shows that Americans overwhelmingly support an increase in the minimum wage: 82% said it was an important priority and only 6% opposed an increase. The minimum wage is a popular issue because Americans believe that everyone deserves the opportunity to earn a decent wage, whether they're a young worker trying to earn money for college or a single mother supporting a family. The minimum wage is about fairness, the value of work, and the opportunities that work provides.

Despite its importance and popularity, lawmakers have not made raising the minimum wage a priority and have let its purchasing power fall every year since 1997. The minimum wage is now worth no more than it was before the last federal increase and worth less than in all but two of the last 48 years. Its value is lower relative to the average wage than it has been since the 1950s.



The last minimum wage increase, from $4.25 to $5.15 in 1996-97, improved the earnings of 9.9 million workers, or 8.9% of the workforce. Because it did so without negative economic consequences, it provided a useful benchmark for crafting a successful minimum wage package. A proposal in the same vein by several senators earlier this year would raise the federal minimum wage from $5.15 to $7.25 in three steps over two years. This proposal would directly raise the wages of 7.3 million workers (5.8% of the workforce), and would therefore be likely to have an even smaller effect on the economy than the last federal increase while still having significant benefits for working families.

Last week, Senator Rick Santorum (R.-Pa.) announced an alternative plan—raising the federal minimum wage to $6.25 over the next two years. While an improvement over the current level, $6.25 would still be an inadequate federal wage floor. It would directly affect fewer than one-fourth the number of workers than an increase to $7.25, benefiting only 1.4% of the workforce. It would also fail to restore the purchasing power of the minimum wage to its 1997 level.
 
Care4all said:
IT is DEAD in its tracks already....thanks to the lovely and pure and moral and honest Republicans we have in office! :(
Poison Pill is the relevant phrase, I think.

Looks like any increase to the minimum wage will have to wait until next year -- or 2009, depending on the outcome of the midterm elections.
 
Desh your link has nothing to do with your statement.

Care, I didn't say that all min wage earners were kids, I included slackers and fools.
 
Back
Top