Why was Wong Kim a citizen?
I told you sycophants the constitution was clear!
- Thread starter Jarod
- Start date
FastLane
Verified User
Wong Kim Ark's parents were LEGAL PERMANENT citizens. Illegal Aliens aren't permanent citizens so their kids aren't Americans like Ark was.
FastLane
Verified User
Because his parents were legal permanent citizens when he was born. Why wasn't Elk an American citizen.
FastLane
Verified User
Not true if he killed an American he would have been arrested by a Federal Marshal.
Not if he did it on the reservation where he was born.
Where does the constitution say anything about the parents citizenship, dumb shit?
Where does the constitution say anything about the parents citizenship?
Where did they grow you? You hate Trump 100 times more than you love America. Simply a disgusting human.
FastLane
Verified User
FastLane
Verified User
Have you read the whole Wong Ark decision? Have you read the whole Elk decision
Yes trueNot true
Then I will Admit I was wrong about my prediction.
It would not be the first time, but im not wrong.
I will continue to believe what I believe, unless they write an opinion I find persuasive.
I
I have
Where does the constitution say anything about the parents citizenship?
FastLane
Verified User
Have you read the Ark or the Elk decision? Both of them talk about the nationality of their parents. Are you aware the Justice Horace Gray was on both cases and was part of the majority opinion on both cases. In both Ark and Elk the allegiance of the parent is pivotal to the case.
FastLane
Verified User
Then you should know both cases discuss Ark and Elks's parent's nationality. It is central to their cases.
FastLane
Verified User
You are full of shit. When Indians killed other Indians we let them work it out. When Indians killed an American the federal government prosecuted them.
The Major Crimes Act of 1885 or (18 U.S.C. § 1153), enacted as section 9 of the Indian Appropriations Act, 1886, Major_Crimes_Act Original Statute-is a law passed by the United States Congress. The law places certain crimes under federal jurisdiction if they are committed by a Native American in Native territory. The law follows the 1817 General Crimes Act,a which extended federal jurisdiction to crimes committed in Native territory but did not cover crimes committed by Native Americans against Native Americans.
Major Crimes Act - Wikipedia
where does the Constitution say the citizenship of the parents is relevant?
Central?