Comparative analysis with other members. My favorite time for hunting socks is Friday and Saturday evenings since that's the most common time people drink resulting in the most common time for them to make mistakes and lose inhibitions.
I don't know how your software operates nor how difficult it would be to compare IP addresses of members, but those would be the best nights to compare over the past year, IMO.
As for rules, not only is it your forum, but some of your rules leave a lot to discretion:
13. No Self-Moderation of the Board. Definition: making a thread unreadable through using extra large fonts or other means to block usage of a thread/forum. Rules will be enforced by the Administration or by Staff Members... Let's be adult here....
14. The treatment of Incendiary Troll accounts. Definition: Posting solely for reaction, to harass, or stalk. Whether single or secondary, those accounts posting solely for reaction and/or harassment and not contributing to the discussion in any way post at the sole discretion of the JPP Admin Team and may be removed at any moment.