The Snyder Act and Birthright Citizenship

[Jarod]

All we need is 5 and we have 6.

Roberts and AOC and usually Kavanaugh are not hacks.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

Roberts and AOC and usually Kavanaugh are not hacks.

AOC? Who is that?

 

[ExpressLane]

It has been settled in every criminal and civil case ever before the courts. The first step of any court case is settling jurisdiction. If you do not settle that, it is impossible to have a court case. This is the most settled law in common law.

Elk_v._Wilkins
In a 7–2 decision, the Supreme Court ruled that even though Elk was born in the United States, he was not a citizen because he owed allegiance to his tribe when he was born rather than to the United States, and therefore was not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States when he was born. The United States Congress later enacted the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, which established citizenship for Indians previously excluded by the Constitution.

 

[ExpressLane]

Roberts and AOC and usually Kavanaugh are not hacks.

Her vote will not help you.

 

[ExpressLane]

An example of that is Native Americans born on reservations. They were not US citizens until 1924 with the Indian Citizenship Act. Even then, in some cases a Native American could still reject citizenship or be rejected for it.

 

[ExpressLane]

Native American sovereignty has become more complex over the years, and it started out complex.

So you lose

 

[Jarod]

AOC? Who is that?

Oops, Amy Barrett

 

[Daylight63]

The real question on the table is:

If a child is born to foreign citizen parents while in the US and those parents are committing the crime of illegal immigration--yes, it is a fucking crime--should their child or they benefit from their criminal activity?

If you say yes, the child should be given citizenship, then you are arguing that the parents, and child, get to benefit from the commission of a crime.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

Oops, Amy Barrett

Okay. Yeah, she's not consistent. I still believe that the Supreme Court should make a decision on this. I'll take the chance.

 

[Jarod]

Okay. Yeah, she's not consistent. I still believe that the Supreme Court should make a decision on this. I'll take the chance.

Okay. Yeah, she's not consistent. I still believe that the Supreme Court should make a decision on this. I'll take the chance.

I think it’s silly and they may not even take it.

 

[T. A. Gardner]

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

The country is divided over it. That's why the Supreme Court needs to clarify it. In my opinion.

 

[ExpressLane]

So you admit you have lost the argument.

 

[T. A. Gardner]

So you admit you have lost the argument.

I'm not the one that invoked Nazis...

 

[Damocles]

AOC? Who is that?

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez? (I think he meant ACB)...

 

[martin]

So you lose

You lose. Your argument rests on a false premise. The meaning of the 14th Amendment doesn't lie with Congress. The Snyder Act was unnecessary for all you know.

 

[Daylight63]

So you admit you have lost the argument.

No, I admit you guys ALWAYS wind up sounding like Nazis. You can't help it. Your leader told people he admires Hitler. So it's on brand.

 

[Daylight63]

If you don't want to have MAGA compared to Nazis then just have them do fewer Nazi type things.

 

[T. A. Gardner]

If you don't want to have MAGA compared to Nazis then just have them do fewer Nazi type things.

If you don't want your posts called delusional hyperbole, stop posting delusional hyperbole.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

If you don't want to have MAGA compared to Nazis then just have them do fewer Nazi type things.

Such as?