G
Guns Guns Guns
Guest
Discuss...
Many military related PTSD patients are known gun nuts. When discovered during treatment the VA is compelled by law to notify the authorities. It has been only a CYA (cover your ass) notification and usually nothing further has happened. I hope and expect that to change significantly and soon.
Canceled.2014.1
New member
First I would ask what you consider "hoarding guns". I have a number of firearms. Some are collector pieces. Most are either for hunting or target shooting.
How many guns does one have to have before it become "hoarding"?
How many guns does one have to have before it become "hoarding"?
G
Guns Guns Guns
Guest
Good question. Let's see your inventory.
Excellent!!!!!!!!
Canceled.2014.1
New member
So it would depend on the type of guns rather than a number? What is the criteria?
Canceled.2014.1
New member
My inventory is excellent? Or is asking to see my inventory without defining "hoarding guns" or giving the criteria for which guns would make it hoarding?
G
Guns Guns Guns
Guest
Let's see your inventory so I can make an informed decision.
WB, I have great respect for you and I consider you reasonable and a friend on these issues as we have stood on the same side of this battlefield on several occasions. I have a little advise for you now. If you feel like someone is calling you a gun hoarder even though they haven't done that at all then you might do some introspection. You just might be a gun hoarder. Ditto on the gun nut question. I hope you can understand the concerns.
I was responding to Hottie. Your concern belies your complexes. Introspection getting to 'ya?
Canceled.2014.1
New member
An informed decision? How will you do that? Is the decision based on the number of guns, the types of guns, the volume of ammunition stored or some other criteria?
If you are going to accuse people of hoarding guns, you need to be able to define what you mean. You cannot expect to be given an inventory so that you can simply proclaim that one is hoarding and one is not.
Canceled.2014.1
New member
Single word answers rarely give much clarity. Which is why I asked for clarification. Much like I asked Legion for clarification.
I see I received as much clarity from you as I did from him.
G
Guns Guns Guns
Guest
By examining your inventory.
Not sure yet.
Did I "accuse" you of hoarding? I don't recall doing that.
You boasted that you have "a number of firearms...collector pieces".
I'm just curious. Why so defensive?
Cancel 2018. 3
<-- sched 2, MJ sched 1
so true. essentially what 'mr. pro gun rights' (according to grind) is saying:
i will make a determination as i see fit based on my subjective view of what is hoarding.
thank goodness only grind sees him as pro second amendment.
Canceled.2014.1
New member
You will base your determination of whether I am hoarding guns on my inventory, and yet you have not offered one iota of information about how you will make the determination.
That is what I thought. I'm sure you can see why I would have my doubts as to your accuracy in determining who is hoarding and who is not?
I don't recall saying you accused me of anything.
I do indeed have a number of firearms. And I do indeed have a few collectors pieces.
I am not defensive at all. I simply asked you to define "hoarding guns".
Hoarders come in all types, colors and configurations, dammy. Why be so persnickety? Are you and WB feeling persecuted? How long have these thoughts been bothering you? Have you sought help with them before?
Canceled.2014.1
New member
Here are two inventory lists. Can you tell me if either of them represents "hoarding guns"?
List #1
1) Ruger No. 1 in .270 Win
2) Ruger Super Blackhawk
3) Ruger 10/22
4) Marlin 1895 Guide Gun in 45-70 Govt
5) Remington M700 in 7mm magnum
6) Remington Model 35 single shot .22 (circa 1927)
7) S&W Hammerless in .38 S&W (circa 1935)
8) Ruger Blackhawk “50th Anniversary of the .44 Magnum”
9) Browning Citori 12 ga O/U
10) Remington 870 12 ga
11) Savage Single shot 16 ga
12) Ruger Single Six .22lr/.22WMR
List #2
1) Ruger No. 1 in .270 Win
2) Ruger Super Blackhawk
3) Marlin 1895 Guide Gun in 45-70 Govt
4) Bushmaster M4 Carbine .223 Rem.
5) Glock 17 9mm
6) Remington Model 35 single shot .22 (circa 1927)
7) S&W Hammerless in .38 S&W (circa 1935)
List #1
1) Ruger No. 1 in .270 Win
2) Ruger Super Blackhawk
3) Ruger 10/22
4) Marlin 1895 Guide Gun in 45-70 Govt
5) Remington M700 in 7mm magnum
6) Remington Model 35 single shot .22 (circa 1927)
7) S&W Hammerless in .38 S&W (circa 1935)
8) Ruger Blackhawk “50th Anniversary of the .44 Magnum”
9) Browning Citori 12 ga O/U
10) Remington 870 12 ga
11) Savage Single shot 16 ga
12) Ruger Single Six .22lr/.22WMR
List #2
1) Ruger No. 1 in .270 Win
2) Ruger Super Blackhawk
3) Marlin 1895 Guide Gun in 45-70 Govt
4) Bushmaster M4 Carbine .223 Rem.
5) Glock 17 9mm
6) Remington Model 35 single shot .22 (circa 1927)
7) S&W Hammerless in .38 S&W (circa 1935)
Canceled.2014.1
New member
Considering that authorities will be notified and you stated " It has been only a CYA (cover your ass) notification and usually nothing further has happened. I hope and expect that to change significantly and soon.", I think defining the parameters of what is considered "hoarding guns" is a legitimate question.
yes, hoarders come in all types, colors and configurations. Some people hoard everything and some only hoard specific items.
But we are talking about hoarding guns. That is why I asked about that. Is it based on how many guns? Is it based on what type of guns? Why is that hard to answer?
