Film Review: SICKO!

Actually private healthcare is still, at this time, outlawed in Canada. The courts put off a ruling for another year to allow some privitization in Quebec.


You clearly haven't read any of the links I provided from Canadian sources about their own system. It also needs improvement, and one of the ways would be to allow some privatized systems.

I agree, we work with the "best" and improve the system that is implemented by studying the problems.


My entire paternal side of my family is Candian Damo. I most certainly do realize the upsides and downsides of their system. I've never suggested we have to copy it 100%.
 
My entire paternal side of my family is Candian Damo. I most certainly do realize the upsides and downsides of their system. I've never suggested we have to copy it 100%.
I just grow tired of every time somebody shows that there are problems we may want to address before we adopt such a system is somehow, "Promoting the status quo" as if they are hand in hand with CATO. While I agree with them often, that doesn't mean that when I suggest we should study the problems in other systems and improve on them while implementing a different solution that I am somehow attempting to promote the status quo.
 
I broke it in Sussex on a Friday night - they told me ENT specialists were off and that there wouldn't be one on until Tuesday there. So, naturally I went back to London, we're I called every hospital, and since I could breath, no would take me to even look at me until the following week some time. Keep in mind my nasal cavity was SHATTERED. I had no bridge to my nose and the cartilage was poking through the skin. It was extremely bad. And I could'nt even get seen for days.

The contrast is that the following Tuesday I hopped a plane back home, saw a doctor that afternoon and was in surgery by Friday. God only knows how long it would have taken me to get a surgeon and actually have it done. My doctors said the surgery that I need to have done should be done within 14 days of the initial break or they'd have to break my nose again which could lead to more scarring. Long story short we just need to figure out a way to get more people insured, and not make everything government run.

There are a lot of horror stories in this country too, and with people who have insurance...forget it if you don't have it.

I think we can do it better. Certainly better than we are doing it now, and I believe better than the UK is doing it.
 
I just grow tired of every time somebody shows that there are problems we may want to address before we adopt such a system is somehow, "Promoting the status quo" as if they are hand in hand with CATO. While I agree with them often, that doesn't mean that when I suggest we should study the problems in other systems and improve on them while implementing a different solution that I am somehow attempting to promote the status quo.

I agree with you! You are the one who is insisting that someone has ever said that Canada is great! We should totally copy Canada.
 
Tiana, did they at least give you any medication for the pain of the broken nose?

Hey, I had pancretitis, and if you want to know pain, get that.

I was fully insured. I waited an entire evening, and then, through the night and till morning, to be admitted at Stony Brook University Medical Center, which is supposed to be a great hospital.

And, I might still be sitting there if my fiance didn't freak out finally at about 4am, and threaten to tear the place apart.

And I got no pain medication. And again, you can't imagine the pain.
 
I've never suggested copying exactly what other countries have.

There's never going to be a perfect system. Our system is totally fucked up now, but when some CATO dude points to an alleged waiting line in canada, there's only one motive for doing that in my book: to protect the status quo.

Britians system is entirely nationalized. Hospitals are run by the goverment, and health care workers and doctors are all government employees. That's never going to happen there.

I'd take a look at the best of the French system, the canadian, system, the UK system, the australian system, etc. and try to adopt the best elements.

Cypress, I didn't know you read info that CATO put out. What CATO guy said there were long lines in Canada?
 
I agree with you! You are the one who is insisting that someone has ever said that Canada is great! We should totally copy Canada.
Again, all I have suggested is that their system is problematic, then my answer was "so what?" I then gave reason why we should pay attention to the problems in other systems.

Somebody suggested that CATO lied, and made a post that ignored problems with Canada's system. I pointed out that there are problems with their system, and that we should pay attention to it. For that I got, "Who cares?"

Again, if we don't want the same problems we need to pay attention to them, ascertain their cause, and fix such problems in any system we implement here.
 
Again, all I have suggested is that their system is problematic, then my answer was "so what?" I then gave reason why we should pay attention to the problems in other systems.

Somebody suggested that CATO lied, and made a post that ignored problems with Canada's system. I pointed out that there are problems with their system, and that we should pay attention to it. For that I got, "Who cares?"

That is because, as you might know, lobbyists and free market ideologues have used the problems within the Canadian system, to scare people in this country from Universal health care.

Now, studying them, so that we can solve them when we implement our own system, is a rational, common sense approach. And being a rational, sensible woman, I have no problem with that, and agree that it is a good idea.
 
Cypress, I didn't know you read info that CATO put out. What CATO guy said there were long lines in Canada?

Cawacko, darling, in your own article that you posted on the thread you called Health Care, the guy from Cato uses alleged waiting periods in Sweden and the Uk as an argument.
 
Cawacko, darling, in your own article that you posted on the thread you called Health Care, the guy from Cato uses alleged waiting periods in Sweden and the Uk as an argument.
It seems that "alleged" waiting in the UK is very real. How long did LadyT say it would have taken her to get her nose looked at?

I can't imagine going into a pressurized plane with such a problem, I am sorry that she had to go through that much pain just to get here and have her nose dealt with before they would have had to rebreak it.
 
It seems that "alleged" waiting in the UK is very real. How long did LadyT say it would have taken her to get her nose looked at?

I can't imagine going into a pressurized plane with such a problem, I am sorry that she had to go through that much pain just to get here and have her nose dealt with before they would have had to rebreak it.

His question was "who from Cato has ever" so I answered that.

I don't think the UK's system ranks very high, and I'm not saying there aren't problems with it, nor would I say that one person's experience is enough to indict the entire system, nor would I ever imagine that Cato is not inflating their numbers on any wait in any of these countries. I'm sure they would like people to believe that no one in this country ever waits, as well.

That's not true. My nephew needs his tonsils out. They can't get him in until August. Now, if he couldn't breath? I'm sure they could get him in. See, the devil is in the details, and we don't get details in these broad "waiting periods" do we Damo?
 
Tiana, did they at least give you any medication for the pain of the broken nose?

yes. I got medicated fairly quickly and when I went into the ER, they saw me pretty quickly too. But that may have only been because I was scaring the other patients with my drama-queen screaming. I always suspected that they gave me something to calm me down in addition to pain killers. For some reason about 20 minutes after I'd taken the pills they gave me I was earily calm.

But I needed to see a specialist then and there. Apparently the fragments that were in my face were pretty close to nerves and that could have caused blindness or other permanent damage. They stabilized me for free and fairly quickly.
 
Hey, I had pancretitis, and if you want to know pain, get that.

I was fully insured. I waited an entire evening, and then, through the night and till morning, to be admitted at Stony Brook University Medical Center, which is supposed to be a great hospital.

And, I might still be sitting there if my fiance didn't freak out finally at about 4am, and threaten to tear the place apart.

And I got no pain medication. And again, you can't imagine the pain.

That sucks big time.
 
yes. I got medicated fairly quickly and when I went into the ER, they saw me pretty quickly too. But that may have only been because I was scaring the other patients with my drama-queen screaming. I always suspected that they gave me something to calm me down in addition to pain killers. For some reason about 20 minutes after I'd taken the pills they gave me I was earily calm.

But I needed to see a specialist then and there. Apparently the fragments that were in my face were pretty close to nerves and that could have caused blindness or other permanent damage. They stabilized me for free and fairly quickly.

Well, I expect more than being stablized. We stabalize people here too, unless we suspect they are homeless and we can get away with dumping them on the street with the garbage.
 
That sucks big time.

The worse part of the whole thing was that the doctor's kept insisting that to get pancretitis you have to be a big drinker. And I'm not, and wasn't, and hadn't been drinking at all in months. But finally, just to get them to shut up, because they were like SF and Damo, they weren't going to give me any peace until I agreed with them, I finally said, you know, you're right, I did have a couple of drinks about a week ago. And they were very pleased and said, well, for you that could be all it took, everybody's system is different. And I just nodded. And they finally left my room, and that's all I cared about.
 
The worse part of the whole thing was that the doctor's kept insisting that to get pancretitis you have to be a big drinker. And I'm not, and wasn't, and hadn't been drinking at all in months. But finally, just to get them to shut up, because they were like SF and Damo, they weren't going to give me any peace until I agreed with them, I finally said, you know, you're right, I did have a couple of drinks about a week ago. And they were very pleased and said, well, for you that could be all it took, everybody's system is different. And I just nodded. And they finally left my room, and that's all I cared about.

That doesn't sound like a good hospital to me. Were they holding your treatment hostage?
 
I have to say everyone in England I ran into was extremely nice and pleasant. I've seen a lot of miserable SOBs in triage here.
 
That doesn't sound like a good hospital to me. Were they holding your treatment hostage?

It's a teaching hospital, and I hate it. It has a really good reputation, and I guess if you need heart surgery, that's great. But for me, all it ended up doing, was putting a bunch of interns in my room, asking me questions. No, they didn't hold my treatment hostage, they just annoyed me and I wanted to rest, so I told them what they wanted to hear.
 
It's a teaching hospital, and I hate it. It has a really good reputation, and I guess if you need heart surgery, that's great. But for me, all it ended up doing, was putting a bunch of interns in my room, asking me questions. No, they didn't hold my treatment hostage, they just annoyed me and I wanted to rest, so I told them what they wanted to hear.

That sucks big time. For my nose I went to my local surgeon. Worked out well for me. Until they had to take the stints out. That was worse than the actual break. I won't even tell you about that.
 
Back
Top