In Light of the Rittenhouse Verdict... A Question

[volsrock]

In the event of a shoot out between two armed people...both can now claim self defense right?

If i body slam u to the ground in a parking lot and my buddy pulls a pistol...u can pull yours and shoot both of us

 

[BattleofHodow]

He didn't mention Rittenhouse's name.

How dare we mention Rittenhouse in a thread dedicated to Rittenhouse.

 

[Micawber]

This person is now on the same level as TDAK and the other four or five people that I have on ignore. So stupid…

Wow, with your estimable internet credentials in this rarefied intellectual atmosphere I am so ashamed. Block me already. See exactly how much I care.

 

[BidenPresident]

Wow, with your estimable internet credentials in this rarefied intellectual atmosphere I am so ashamed. Block me already. See exactly how much I care.

I love right winger declaring that they're the sane ones. The ones who think Trump was elected president.

 

[volsrock]

In the event of a shoot out between two armed people...both can now claim self defense right?

A person who was the initial aggressor cannot claim self-defense as a justification unless they abandon the combat or the other party has responded with excessive force.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-... allowing a,be accompanied by excessive force.


TITLE 14 - Criminal Law
RS 14:21 - Aggressor cannot claim self defense

Universal Citation: LA Rev Stat § 14:21
§21. Aggressor cannot claim self defense

A person who is the aggressor or who brings on a difficulty cannot claim the right of self-defense unless he withdraws from the conflict in good faith and in such a manner that his adversary knows or should know that he desires to withdraw and discontinue the conflict.



The person who started the fight is generally considered to deserve every bad consequence of that fight, no matter how bad it is.

 

[Micawber]

Two Americas.

Trumpers and everyone else.

 

[BidenPresident]

Trumpers and everyone else.

Indeed. We'll gather them up in a net and toss them in prison.

 

[volsrock]

You can go into a bar and start a fight. Then kill that person in self defense.

you can break a window of a government building and start to climb though "unarmed" and get shot by someone that gets a pass because he states it was done in defense of others

 

[leaningright]

I love right winger declaring that they're the sane ones. The ones who think Trump was elected president.

He was elected…once. Once…

 

[BidenPresident]

you can break a window of a government building and start to climb though "unarmed" and get shot by someone that gets a pass because he states it was done in defense of others

Babbitt deserved to die. They all did.

 

[volsrock]

Babbitt deserved to die. They all did.

So did the child molester

 

[BidenPresident]

So did the child molester

Your father?

 

[volsrock]

Your father?

12b

suggesting posters may have been molested as a kid

https://www.justplainpolitics.com/showthread.php?2-Rules-of-the-Board!

 

[BidenPresident]

12b

suggesting posters may have been molested as a kid

https://www.justplainpolitics.com/showthread.php?2-Rules-of-the-Board!

you're on ignore. enough out of you

 

[volsrock]

you're on ignore. enough out of you

u suggested a posters father was a child molester

 

[ThatOwlWoman]

In the event of a shoot out between two armed people...both can now claim self defense right?

Yes.

This is especially true if you are armed and the other guy just has a skateboard, or a sack of sandwiches, or a bag of Skittles.

 

[volsrock]

Yes.

This is especially true if you are armed and the other guy just has a GLOCK PISTOL, skateboard, or a sack of sandwiches, or a bag of Skittles.

Fixed it for you

One of the POS that came at Kyle pointed a Glock at him


What was Ashli Babbitt armed with?

 

[]2epo]v[an]

In the event of a shoot out between two armed people...both can now claim self defense right?

Depends I'd guess. If it was a mutually agreed upon shootout, the survivor could be liable for any innocent bystanders hit by the decedent. Assuming anyone lives.

 

[Sirthinksalot]

If i body slam u to the ground in a parking lot and my buddy pulls a pistol...u can pull yours and shoot both of us

I thought you were a little old lady. Can you actually body slam people?

 

[]2epo]v[an]

You can go into a bar and start a fight. Then kill that person in self defense.

If you committed a criminal act you first have to successfully retreat to the wall. Meaning, you have to run away until you're caught, cornered, or know you're going to be forced to use lethal force, such as: three people chasing you thinking you have a knife with the reassurance that they too have knives. "He has a knife!" "So what, we have knives also".

Side note, even a shot through both lungs and two ventricles takes 30 seconds to kill you. That's a whole lot of time for someone with a knife to cut you up.

In close quarters, a knife is better than a gun.

And there's usually stipulation in case law where it comes to altered states of mind. Bars are where you go to do that kind of thing, sooooo.