Bravely Drawing Mohammed...

[blackascoal]

SO you agree he legally can, and would fight to the death for his right to do it. Good.

He can commit any stupid ass act he chooses to, but it would not be at the expense of my life. If he gets killed for it .. too fucking bad. He should have been smarter.

You have the right to drown yourself, just don't expect me to drown with you.

 

[Litmus]

He can commit any stupid ass act he chooses to, but it would not be at the expense of my life. If he gets killed for it .. too fucking bad. He should have been smarter.

You have the right to drown yourself, just don't expect me to drown with you.

But you agree he does and should have the right to do it, in a free and open society. Good for you.

Would you die for free speech laws in general? Or you really think some people have a right to free speech and some don't.

 

[blackascoal]

But you agree he does and should have the right to do it, in a free and open society. Good for you.

Would you die for free speech laws in general? Or you really think some people have a right to free speech and some don't.

Your inability to articulate your own thoughts in a mature and intelligent manner does not lend itself to any sanity in you trying to speak for me.

I have been very clear about what I think of this fool and if he gets killed fior this .. who the fuck cares? This is not an issue of free speech as much as you keep trying to twist it into one. He lives in Sweden and they enjoy more free speech than you do.

 

[Litmus]

Your inability to articulate your own thoughts in a mature and intelligent manner does not lend itself to any sanity in you trying to speak for me.

I have been very clear about what I think of this fool and if he gets killed fior this .. who the fuck cares? This is not an issue of free speech as much as you keep trying to twist it into one. He lives in Sweden and they enjoy more free speech than you do.

This is a free speech issue, especially if you won't say you support it unconditionally.

No they don't. They will be jailed for denying the holocaust.

 

[blackascoal]

This is a free speech issue, especially if you won't say you support it unconditionally.

That's just bullshit, but feel free to characterize it anyway you choose. Doesn't matter.

And NO, hell no, I do not support free speech unconditionally. In an intelligent society, intelligence is always required. I recognize how that, intelligence, can be a problem.

No they don't. They will be jailed for denying the holocaust.

Granted, you're right.

 

[Litmus]

That's just bullshit, but feel free to characterize it anyway you choose. Doesn't matter.

And NO, hell no, I do not support free speech unconditionally. In an intelligent society, intelligence is always required. I recognize how that, intelligence, can be a problem.



Granted, you're right.

But you unconditionally support it in the case of religious criticism or satire? RIght? Im not talking about yelling fire in a theatre.

Do you believe drawing mohammed with a dog body should be outlawed as Hate Speech? THis is a simple yes or no question. Can you handle it?

 

[blackascoal]

But you unconditionally support it in the case of religious criticism or satire? RIght? Im not talking about yelling fire in a theatre.

Do you believe drawing mohammed with a dog body should be outlawed as Hate Speech? THis is a simple yes or no question. Can you handle it?

Why should I play the strawman game? Who, what, and when has anyone declared that his kindergarten drawing should be declared as hate speech? WTF are you talking about?

Is it possible for you to stay on point in this discussion?

Let me repeat AGAIN for you .. It's not a question of if he could, that has never been the issue. The issue is if he should have done it and/or if his ignorant act could be considered "brave"

Can you handle that?

 

[Litmus]

Why should I play the strawman game? Who, what, and when has anyone declared that his kindergarten drawing should be declared as hate speech? WTF are you talking about?

Is it possible for you to stay on point in this discussion?

Let me repeat AGAIN for you .. It's not a question of if he could, that has never been the issue. The issue is if he should have done it and/or if his ignorant act could be considered "brave"

Can you handle that?

Just consider it a naturally occurring issue considering the content of the thread. There's an obvious connection to the subject at hand.

LET'S MAKE it an issue of legality, hypothetically, for the sake of argument. Can you handle that?

Let's see.

Should expressions such as this be outlawed under Hate Speech legislation?

Handle it.

 

[blackascoal]

Just consider it a naturally occurring issue considering the content of the thread. There's an obvious connection to the subject at hand.

LET'S MAKE it an issue of legality, hypothetically, for the sake of argument. Can you handle that?

Let's see.

Should expressions such as this be outlawed under Hate Speech legislation?

Handle it.

Answer, NO

QUESTION: When was whether his "expression" was legal or not ever been the issue in this thread?

So let me ask the question more germaine to this thread ..

Was his "expression" an intelligent thing to do considering that more was at stake than just his own safety?

I have a daughter that's stuck in hell and surrounded by devout believers in the Prophet .. and there are thousands of other parents, brothers, sisters, wives, and children who have loved ones stuck in the same hell my daughter is in.

Do you have such a loved one stuck there or in Afghanistan?

I ask so I'll know how to properly weight your answer.

 

[Litmus]

Answer, NO

QUESTION: When was whether his "expression" was legal or not ever been the issue in this thread?

I made it an issue. Right at the end here. Thanks for finally answering the question.

So let me ask the question more germaine to this thread ..

Was his "expression" an intelligent thing to do considering that more was at stake than just his own safety?

I have a daughter that's stuck in hell and surrounded by devout believers in the Prophet .. and there are thousands of other parents, brothers, sisters, wives, and children who have loved ones stuck in the same hell my daughter is in.

Do you have such a loved one stuck there or in Afghanistan?

I ask so I'll know how to properly weight your answer.

Then appeasing your daughers captors is pretty fucking dumb.