NiftyNiblick
1960s Chick Magnet
I don't agree with that analysis and conclusion.
Canada is every bit as diverse, maybe more so and they have all those benefits.
What Canada does not have is the hard core, hard right racist, backward looking derps.
it is not less diversity and more homogony (around white derps) that would make America more progressive. It is the loss of the right derps. They are being bred out of existence thankfully as their kids each generation are more progressive. And when those white racist, backwards derps are such a small part of the population, diversity will be higher and America will progress.
I understand your belief, but in the end, it doesn't coincide with what I believe or actually observe.
Also, as generations go on, the mosaic becomes more of an actual melting pot and diversity actually diminishes,
but that will take at least another half-millennium and one would have to believe the republic has that long of a future.