Evolution controversy erupts

PostmodernProphet said:
......I love it when you talk all "sciencey"......
Click to expand...

While the notions you entertain are quite impossible. For instance, accurate accounts of a 115000 year old event passed orally or a complete break from one species to another within a single generation. Your thoughts are laughable and stupid just like the question you are using in hopes of changing the focus.
 
Last edited:
Professor Baxter said:
You first. Explain how you think speciation is supposed to occur. You have been asked through several threads and you just continue to try to change the subject.
Click to expand...

not true....as I said, it happens in isolation.....where one strain of a creature breeds apart from the general population......

meanwhile there are two questions you've been running from......

one, an example of multi-regional evolution......

two.....if homo-erectus evolved multi-regionally, why did they all end up in Africa whether it be 115k or 65k years ago?.......
 
PostmodernProphet said:
not true....as I said, it happens in isolation.....where one strain of a creature breeds apart from the general population......

meanwhile there are two questions you've been running from......

one, an example of multi-regional evolution......

two.....if homo-erectus evolved multi-regionally, why did they all end up in Africa whether it be 115k or 65k years ago?.......
Click to expand...

That's not a straight answer.

So is it among a group of animals genetically isolated or does a member of one species suddenly give birth to a new species as you had previously indicated? If you understand that it is among a group then why are you having trouble understanding that it might happen within the entire population?

I have not run from any of your questions. I will answer some MORE of yours when you give a full answer to this ONE I have been asking you through several threads and 1000s of posts. I can give you a long list of species that are evolving across a wide range of regions.

On your question 2... what are you talking about? Fossils of homo erectus older than 115000 have been found outside of Africa. Again, the recent find is of a 2 million year old skull in the country of Georgia.
 
PostmodernProphet said:
???...why would either be impossible?......
Click to expand...

Arguing that the Noah story passed accurately for 115000 years is exponentially more crazy than arguing the accuracy of tales about Robin Hood or King Arthur. It's a fable or myth and even with Ussher's dating a rational person does not treat it as a historical event. It's even stranger that you do when you also argue that it's inaccurate on key points.
 
Professor Baxter said:
does a member of one species suddenly give birth to a new species as you had previously indicated?
Click to expand...

???....as I indicated what.....a member of a species gives birth to an offspring that either is identical to the rest of the species or has a variation of some type.....if the offspring survives it may pass that variation on to its offspring or the variation may die off.....

If you understand that it is among a group
Click to expand...

groups don't have an offspring....a couple does.....or is a village raising your child?.....

I can give you a long list of species that are evolving across a wide range of regions.
Click to expand...

can you give me ONE species that evolved in more than one region?.......
 
Professor Baxter said:
Arguing that the Noah story passed accurately for 115000 years is exponentially more crazy than arguing the accuracy of tales about Robin Hood or King Arthur. It's a fable or myth and even with Ussher's dating a rational person does not treat it as a historical event. It's even stranger that you do when you also argue that it's inaccurate on key points.
Click to expand...

so basically, it is impossible simply because you don't believe it to be possible......and you say I am at fault for claiming it inaccurate because it couldn't possibly be accurate....../grins.....
 
PostmodernProphet said:
???....as I indicated what.....a member of a species gives birth to an offspring that either is identical to the rest of the species or has a variation of some type.....if the offspring survives it may pass that variation on to its offspring or the variation may die off.....



groups don't have an offspring....a couple does.....or is a village raising your child?.....



can you give me ONE species that evolved in more than one region?.......
Click to expand...

Can you stay in context? Do you think that the idea is that speciation occurs due to changes within a population or because one member suddenly gives birth to a new species?

A single child is never identical to existing members of the species in asexual species.

Your 20 year old joke is lame, old man. I did not say anything about groups having offspring.

I can give you a long list of them right after you actually answer my question.
 
PostmodernProphet said:
so basically, it is impossible simply because you don't believe it to be possible......and you say I am at fault for claiming it inaccurate because it couldn't possibly be accurate....../grins.....
Click to expand...

More strawman bullshit. I said it is strange that you defend parts of it while denying the accuracy of other significant parts of the account.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top