Question for our gun enthusiast friends.

[StoneByStone]

The Constitution is the primary law of the land.

Let's say, hypothetically, that muh constitution doesn't exist.
Will laws fail to prevent abortions the way gun enthusiasts claim that laws fail to prevent people from buying guns?

 

[StoneByStone]

Week 5-6.... for the developing child.... *‘

Actually, it's more like week 13. The brain starts developing around week 6, but there's no consciousness until week 13. The earliest you can make the argument for is week 9.

 

[StoneByStone]

So let's deconstruct your strawman argument; who has ever stated that laws or bans will prevent things from ever happening? Anyone?

Everyone who wants abortion to be illegal.

 

[StoneByStone]

It answered your question. That you don't like the answer is your fault, not mine, boy.

You avoided the question. I guess you just don't have the ability to answer it.

 

[StoneByStone]

Last time I looked abortion wasn't mentioned in the constitution Arschloch.

Das ist nicht die Frage.

 

[StoneByStone]

They won't stop abortion. They'll merely stop *safe* abortions.

Hey, look! Someone who actually answered the question!

 

[StoneByStone]

wrong.......it isn't a guinea hen before brain activity and a panda after.......its a living panda before and a living panda after......just like humans.......again, some of you folks don't understand science.......

No, it's a clump of cells before, and eventually it develops a consciousness and a body to become a panda. Did you go to college?

 

[Truth Detector]

Let's say, hypothetically, that muh constitution doesn't exist.

I don't do LAME hypothetical. I prefer to base my arguments on reality. The Constitution exists; pretending that it doesn't is moronic and LAME.

Will laws fail to prevent abortions the way gun enthusiasts claim that laws fail to prevent people from buying guns?

Who has ever stated that gun laws would prevent people from buying guns? The actual argument is that gun laws will not prevent gun crimes. Buying a gun doesn't always lead to a crime. Abortion always leads to murder. See the difference?

 

[TOP]

Actually, it's more like week 13. The brain starts developing around week 6, but there's no consciousness until week 13. The earliest you can make the argument for is week 9.

There's brain activity...and a heartbeat....

 

[StoneByStone]

Who has ever stated that gun laws would prevent people from buying guns? The actual argument is that gun laws will not prevent gun crimes.

One of the arguments I regularly hear is that banning guns wouldn't work because people can just get guns on the black market.

Now if you don't use this argument, ok, but this thread is for people who do use that argument.

 

[StoneByStone]

There's brain activity...and a heartbeat....

A heartbeat doesn't matter. And the brain activity doesn't involve any thoughts or consciousness yet.

 

[TOP]

A heartbeat doesn't matter. And the brain activity doesn't involve any thoughts or consciousness yet.

Of course it does....

 

[ThatOwlWoman]

Of course it does....

Apparently not. Most ppl would say that you, for instance, have some sort of brain activity. But it signifies nothing. lol

 

[Eagle_Eye]

Das ist nicht die Frage.

Au contraire sport.

 

[Truth Detector]

They won't stop abortion. They'll merely stop *safe* abortions.

Abortions are safe? STFU.

 

[Truth Detector]

Apparently not. Most ppl would say that you, for instance, have some sort of brain activity. But it signifies nothing. lol

I R O N Y!!!

 

[CFM]

You avoided the question. I guess you just don't have the ability to answer it.

I answered it. You don't have the ability to acknowledge answers unless it's what you want to hear.

 

[StoneByStone]

I answered it. You don't have the ability to acknowledge answers unless it's what you want to hear.

Sorry you weren't able to understand.

 

[CFM]

Sorry you weren't able to understand.

Sorry you only accept answers that agree with what you support.

 

[Into the Night]

Banning abortion is also unconstitutional.

It is unconstitutional for the federal government to do so. It is NOT unconstitutional for a State to ban abortion. The federal government does not have authority to pass laws concerning murder except for specific cases which are listed in the Constitution.