Is the purpose of that to confuse us? Given our dominance in every field in educational rankings, I don't think it's possible for us to be offended by that
Doesn't matter to me. I don't have a dog in that fight. I didn't attend either school. Though I did work for almost 3 years as a research assistant at OSU graduate school of Ceramic Engineering/Materials Science which was rated #3 nationally in that discipline behind Alfred University and U. Ill. Quite an achievement considering I didn't have a graduate degree, at the time and my undergraduate degree was a BA in human biology. Ended up going to small private schools for graduate work. I learned more in one year at Palmer college than I did in four years at State U.
I think much of the ado about rankings is so much about nothing. I think the accreditation of the school you attend, the curriculum you study and the elbow grease you put into your studies are far more significant. I've known an idiot who graduated from Princeton, a millionaire business man who was a high school drop out and a very successful attorney who never went to college. He earned his law license the old fashioned way. He went from High School to reading law as a clerk at a law firm where it took him 6 years of work and study before he attempted the bar exam and passed it on his first try. Don't know if that's still possible today but it was in my fathers generation.
Take accreditation. All the State Universities and the top tier private schools in the upper midwest have Great Lakes Regional Accreditation. Does that mean that all the schools have the same educational opportunities. Of course it doesn't. But it does mean that the academic standards in the class room are virtually the same. In fact I would argue that in a lot of cases the quality of class room instruction is significantly better at small liberal art colleges and community colleges cause you don't get some damned TA foisted on you like you do at the big research universities. I actually turned down an opportunity to earn my masters at Ohio State when I was working there. The position I was working permitted tuition waver if I took classes but their Environmental Science/Management department was academic in nature and not real world based. So I borrowed money and earned my masters at little Findlay College which has a far superior EH&S program than either OSU or Michigan does....or any Big 10 school for that matter.
Then there's curriculum. A BS in Chemical Engineering from State U is more significant in the marketplace than a communications degree from North Western or Michigan.
Then there's hard work, talent and ability. Sure, having a degree from top tier school may open more doors for you but once you walk through that door....no one gives a rats ass where you went to school. It's all about performing and what have you done for me lately. Same if your an entrepreneur. It's doubtful that your investors and customers care where you wen t to school. They probably care a great deal more about your product/service, business model and performance in the market.
Same with professionals. Ever ask your Physician or P.E. or Lawyer where they went to school or what their GPA was?