BREAKING: Trump says he’s going to overturn the 14th Amendment with an executive order.

[Neil N. Blowme]

The article you linked to was written in 2011. There are some very real legal reasons why it hasn't been acted on and never will be acted on. The piece is nonsense and attempts to cherry pick cases out of context. If citizenship by virtue of being born in the US is eliminated it would result in chaos since everyone born in the US that can't prove their ancestors arrived legally would lose their citizenship.

It's going to be acted upon on January 20th, 2025.

 

[Jarod]

What part of "and not subject to any foreign power” would be considered citizens, do you leftist halfwits fail to comprehend?

That’s not what the amendment says.

 

[IBDaMann]

Dumbest analogy on the planet.

You have wandered into idiot territory. You have no argument.

Those here ILLEGALLY are already criminals.

Pivot. We're not talking about them.

It doesn't matter if they dropped a baby here

The moment you try to claim that a baby born in the US is somehow not a citizen because someone else committed a crime, you lose.

Now, what is your argument?

 

[IBDaMann]

It's going to be acted upon on January 20th, 2025.

It will be reviewed. The end result is that anyone born in the US is a citizen. That is the only possible result until the States take up the issue.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

It will be reviewed. The end result is that anyone born in the US is a citizen. That is the only possible result until the States take up the issue.

Watch what happens.

 

[IBDaMann]

Watch what happens.

We all will. I am just giving you a preview of the outcome.

 

[Poor Richard Saunders]

The amendment was adopted on July 9, 1868. What is your point?



Cherry picking is what halfwits on the left do dipshit. If you are an illegal, or a citizen of another country, birthright citizenship doesn't apply.

I was born in Germany to an American military father. I wasn't automatically a German citizen. In fact, I was born as an American citizen.

But hey, you're mentally unstable and get your talking points from MSNBC which makes you more ignorant and incapable of comprehending the obvious.

It's always amazing how stupid you reveal yourself to be. Germany is not part of the US so doesn't use the US Constitution to decide citizenship. Germany has it's own form of government and it isn't bound by anything in the US Constitution.


By the way, if foreign troops are stationed in the US and one of them has a child, that child would not be a US citizen because the specific class that is not subject to jurisdiction which includes foreign sovereigns, foreign ministers and ambassadors and foreign troops allowed to enter the country. That was decided by the US supreme court in 1812.

I don't watch MSNBC. I read court cases such as this one -

Schooner Exchange v. McFaddon, 11 U.S. 116 (1812)

The Exchange v. McFaddon

supreme.justia.com

The jurisdiction of a nation within its own territory, is exclusive and absolute.

 

[Poor Richard Saunders]

It's going to be acted upon on January 20th, 2025.

If it is acted upon it will never be implemented because the courts will block it because it violates the US Constitution.

I see you have decided to not argue the case on its merits. But then you never were arguing the case on its merits.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

We all will. I am just giving you a preview of the outcome.

I have confidence in the Supreme Court.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

If it is acted upon it will never be implemented because the courts will block it because it violates the US Constitution.

I see you have decided to not argue the case on its merits. But then you never were arguing the case on its merits.

It stops at the Supreme Court and I have confidence in this Supreme Court.

 

[Poor Richard Saunders]

I have confidence in the Supreme Court.

So when they refuse to take the case and let the lower court ruling stand you'll be fine with that? The lower court will rule that the 14th amendment says all persons born in the US are US citizens because that is the only possible reading of the court cases and the Constitution.

 

[Neil N. Blowme]

So when they refuse to take the case and let the lower court ruling stand you'll be fine with that? The lower court will rule that the 14th amendment says all persons born in the US are US citizens because that is the only possible reading of the court cases and the Constitution.

I have a different scenario. Good luck.

 

[Into the Night]

He can't. Sybil is mentally ill. Mentally ill people can't change their patterns of behavior.

I am not you, Sybil.

 

[Into the Night]

What about it I wasn't talking about that.
I was talking about just what Trump's tariffs of 20/30/49 or MORE will do to low income people , the poor, people on SS and our economy.
Again the exporting countries do not pay those tariffs they just pass them on to the consumer.

Tariffs don't cause inflation, Sybil.

 

[Into the Night]

And you aren't a patriot either, A person that backs a want to be dictator like you are the ones that should be deported.

I don't back any dictator, Sybil. You are hallucinating again. i'm Native American. Where would you deport me to?

 

[IBDaMann]

I have confidence in the Supreme Court.

As do I. As such, I am confident that SCOTUS will render the only decision clearly stated by the law, and you know what that is.

 

[Into the Night]

So when they refuse to take the case and let the lower court ruling stand you'll be fine with that? The lower court will rule that the 14th amendment says all persons born in the US are US citizens because that is the only possible reading of the court cases and the Constitution.

DON'T TRY TO HIDE BEHIND THE CONSTITUTION YOU DESPISE!

The 14th amendment does not grant citizenship to anyone.

 

[Into the Night]

Agreed Sybil isn't a patriot.

Plan B is already in action: Sybil can't leave his facility without an escort.

Is that so, Sybil? I noticed you tried to laugh your way out your predicament as well. That won't work, Sybil.

 

[Into the Night]

And those tariffs were not as large as the ones Trump says he is going to impose now.
Tariffs can be good to a POINT but when they are so large they destroy your economy then they are not and that is what Trump's tariffs will do,

Why are you so intent on supporting China??
Tariffs do not destroy an economy.

DEMOCRATS did that when they started the current economic depression.

 

[IBDaMann]

i'm Native American. Where would you deport me to?

I suppose that authorities could escort you to a local airport, have you board a plane that flies a circuit pattern and lands, make you go through immigration and then drive you back to your house.