Yes, I believe that it is un-American to withhold legal representation from anyone, and many if not all of the prisoners in gitmo aren't terrorists.
I feel that accepting a client who resides in Libya, and not America, who blew up an airliner, is a bit beyond the pale though. Personally, I would have turned down the money, but I'd represent those charged and held without trial (clearly un-American) in Gitmo, for free. Not least because they are on American soil and didn't blow up anything. But that's a personal feeling, which we are all going to differ on.
What cannot be debated, and will not be debated is that when you run on a platform of vote for me, because if you vote for them they will let the terrorists get away, and meanwhile, you have been providing legal counseling for people who blew up a civilian aircraft, then that is unacceptable. It's my opinion that whoever runs against him, whether within the r primary, or in the general were he nominated, should just run excerpts from the Times article, Thompson's picture, and the word Unacceptable in red stamped across it.
If I were running the Rudy campaign, who he is a threat to, that is the commercial I would be drawing up right now.