Hello NiftyNiblick,
We both understand that there's a serious problem, PoliTalker.
We couldn't agree less on the solution, unfortunately.
Trump supporters aren't merely wrong.
They're a cancer that need to be cut out.
That leaves partition or war, and partition makes more sense to me.
Conciliation, on the other hand, appears a Pollyanna pipedream to me.
There's no rational argument to defend it as a realistic option.
Are you blind to the seething hatred that surrounds us?
Or are you optimistic because what you want really seems like what can actually be?
I wouldn't want to make that latter argument and have to defend it with Aaristotelian logic.
You're right, we disagree.
There is no clear place to draw the boundaries.
Drawing boundaries will not work.
We have to solve the hate problem.
Tall order, yes, but there is no other viable option.
I do not believe partitioning could work.
Trying really hard to picture it:
Suppose the boundaries are drawn at State lines. Red States, Blue States.
(Forget for a moment the big stink about what to do with purple States.)
What do you do with the adamant Trump fan who lives in a blue State?
He's not going to want to leave. Born and raised there. Proud of his spread. He's not going anywhere. He is going to be pissed off about it.
Just one example.
All this idea will do would be to amp up attitudes and get people fighting mad.
And then you're going to tell him he has to get a passport to cross the same State line he has been crossing his whole life to do business?
He's not gonna like that.
The problem with this idea is that, while you may like it, you cannot assume that everybody else is going to like it.
I don't like it. Lots of people are not going to like it. There is a reason it is not a popular idea.
What if you somehow got a slight majority on it and made it happen anyway?
Now you've got a whole bunch of people who are super-angry at what has happened.
And the idea came from a liberal?
That will not be received well. I can tell you that much.
Not gonna work.
Might as well just ask for a shooting civil war.
Nope.
We have to stay united and solve our difference the best we can.