Should Trump Ban Property Taxes Nationwide?
There are a number of problems even with the constitutionality of the proposal. Congress, not trump, decides federal taxes. This is not even federal taxes, but taxes through the state. The constitution does not seem to even allow Congress to take away this state right.
The way to do this is to have states ban property taxes.
There is a problem beyond that. Property taxes fund a lot of local and state government. It is the way that schools, local police, and roads are funded. There are other taxes that help with all them, but losing property taxes would make a huge hole in local government. In many places, it is the vast majority of local taxes.
trump appears to be claiming that the federal government can just increase their taxes and redistribute the money. he appears to want to cut local schools in areas that did not vote for him.
Tax commercial properties and secondary and on residential properties, but not someone's home.
Unless you rent? So someone has a million dollar home, they get it tax free. Someone rents an apartment, they pay property taxes indirectly?
There are already states and localities with virtually no property taxes.
From his own link:
Unfortunately, every state in the U.S. has some type of property tax.
There are some states that have lower property taxes on senior citizens or disabled veterans, but they pay for that through higher taxes on the rest.
There is no populated part of the USA without any police. If there are no local police, the state police fill in. If there are no state police, federal police fill in. We do not allow there to be a place without law enforcement.
Schools can be funded by other taxes and usually are.
Schools in the USA are mostly funded by property taxes.
In Arizona, there are lots of alternatives to public education, and most are better than public education.
Arizona requires private schools to be funded by property taxes, so back where we started.