'Duck boat' design flaw flagged years ago

Well, here's a little more news with some testimony of 2 survivors (a father & daughter as told to ex-wife/mother).
It seems one of the craft's operators did release the canopy as well.

*************************************************


Mandi Keller spent Thursday night frantically calling police stations and sheriff's offices in southwest Missouri.

Keller was home in Texas, but her 15-year-old daughter, Gillian, was among the 31 people aboard a Ride the Ducks amphibious tour vessel that capsized Thursday night on Table Rock Lake.

Officials say 17 people died.

Gillian survived without serious injuries.

"I feel fortunate," Keller said. "God spared my child and she is coming home alive and not in a body bag."

Keller said Gillian was visiting Branson with her father and his family. Now, everyone is ready to go home.

Keller said her daughter and ex-husband reported the vessel began to sink in the stormy conditions Thursday night, and the occupants were briefly trapped under the boat's canopy.

Eventually, one of the duck boat operators was able to release the canopy and people swam toward the surface, according to the account Keller received.

Keller said her ex-husband reported it took all his strength to swim to the surface since the sinking vessel was sucking people downward.

"My daughter said she thought she was dead," Keller said.

Keller said she was told people aboard the vessel were not wearing life jackets.

Keller said her daughter and ex-husband made it to the surface and then swam to a nearby restaurant where people helped them out of the water.

Keller said Friday she felt lucky her daughter was alive but heartbroken for all the families dealing with fatalities.

Video from witnesses shows the boat struggling as large waves swamped the vessel.

Stone County Sheriff Doug Rader said the boat is believed to have sunk in 40 feet of water, rolled down in the lake, and landed on its wheels in 80-feet deep lake water.

Investigators with the National Transportation Safety Board will be working to determine exactly what happened.

Jim Pulley, owner of Sea Tow Table Rock Lake, said the storm hit the lake with 80 mph winds that kicked up waves five feet high.

http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/go...oat-survivor-speaks-out/ar-BBKSAd2?ocid=ientp
 
Those @#$% boats should be outlawed. They are an 80 year old design never intended for that purpose and the addition of the canopies makes them deathtraps in the event of a swamping or roll over.

Ban, ban, ban. If that isn’t enough regulate ‘em out of business.

Same song, second verse.

My sister and her family just got home from Branson a couple hours ago. Today was a surreal end to their mini vacation.
 
Ban, ban, ban. If that isn’t enough regulate ‘em out of business.

Same song, second verse.

My sister and her family just got home from Branson a couple hours ago. Today was a surreal end to their mini vacation.

Glad they made it back and the duck boat bidness can turn a profit too. There's enough of us and it wasn't me or mine either.
 
Does putting other people down make you feel important or does it make you feel smart? One thing's for certain: It makes you look stupid.

Assessing the reality.
I have been to Branson for work and seen it first hand.
Full of obese redneck hillbillies who love to eat and listen to hillbilly music.
This tragedy could have easily been avoided. The weather was predicted hours before and the boats were overloaded with fat people who were trapped by the canopy and windows.
Those are the facts.
Call me names if you wish, but I speak the facts.
 
Geeze. WTF is wrong with you guys tonight? Not everyone who visits Branson is a redneck or hillbilly -- but fucking what if they were? Do you really want to be like the Reichtards here who wish death on libruls because of who we vote for/are?

I've been on many different types of tourist and commercial water vehicles -- sailboats, commercial fishing boats, tour boats from Alaska to Florida. Not a single one has ever required the passengers to wear life jackets, nor does the Coast Guard require that. They *ARE* required to instruct the passengers before the boat leaves dock where to find them -- as you said, often under the seats, but just as often stored in lockers well-marked by CG regs. Just like when boarding a jet, smart ppl pay attention to the safety briefings, mark the exits, and know where the flotation devices are. I'm pretty sure though that no one on a calm lake like Table Rock thought this type of disaster would happen.

The weather warnings were out hours before it struck.
No Duck boat had any business on the water, overloaded in 60 mph winds.
These deaths were caused by greed and callous disregard for safety.
 
Well then, I am sure you can find some scientific evidence to support that. And also that all those poor souls on that vessel were from Branson. Do not take to long providing that information. Thanks.

I have at stayed at Branson for work several times. I have witnessed the heartland obesity epidemic first hand.
These people eat things like fried mayonnaise and fried butter and they don't care how fat they get.
It is an appalling thing to see.

16essay-popup.jpg

https://www.google.com/search?q=fri...zIMKHV8QD3UQ_AUICSgA&biw=814&bih=478&dpr=1.25
http://friedmayo.com/

Ride The Ducks is part of the Branson Tourism Center.
Branson is like Disneyland for country rednecks. They come from all over the south to eat and see country music shows.
 
Last edited:
Coast Guard regulations do not require duck passengers to wear personal flotation devices (PFDs), which puts them in danger of drowning, Mongeluzzi said. But the devices could pin their wearers against the vessel's canopy, which is what happened to several victims in the Arkansas accident, according to the NTSB.

"If you keep the canopy on, then you're damned if you do and damned if you don't," said Mongeluzzi, who characterizes the canopies as "death cages." "If you put your PFD on, it's harder to get out. If you don't put your PFD on, you're more likely to drown. Passengers on a sightseeing cruise should never be faced with that life-or-death decision."


http://www.cnn.com/2010/US/09/17/duck.boat.safety/index.html

ride-the-ducks-branson1.jpg
 
I remain unconvinced these stats are anymore real than any of your other bullshit lies.

How many on the ducky boats here?


Black children ages 5 to 19 drown in swimming pools at a rate more than five times that of white children, the research found. That suggests a lot of blacks are not learning to swim, said the lead author, Dr. Julie Gilchrist of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.usatoday.com/amp/9146213
 
Back
Top