How much has Obamacare saved the American people?

Oneuli said:
I did. Now it's your turn: what's healthcare inflation been since Obamacare? What was the lowest rate of healthcare inflation for a period of that length before Obamacare.

If you need someone to walk you through the math, just let me know.
Click to expand...

I keep pointing out that reducing the rate of cost increase were not the arguments made to sell Obamacare. Why do you continue ignoring those FACTS?

Americans were told that healthcare costs would actually go down. They were also told they could keep their doctors. They were also told they could keep their plans.

All of these were lies. Why do you keep pontificating about the lower cost of increase when Obamacare has not lived up to ANY of its promises snowflake?

Obama didn't say Obamacare would reduce the rate of increase; he actually claimed they would go DOWN and that they would LOWER the deficit.

Jonathan Gruber Videos: Oneuli "Too Stupid to Understand" Obamacare
[/QUOTE]
 
Legion said:
You want others to speculate on what might have happened...
Click to expand...
Yes, and as you can see from the statistics, my speculation is solidly in line with the hard data. It's not just that we had somewhat below-average healthcare inflation since Obamacare. It's that we set a record, by a pretty substantial margin, for the least healthcare inflation ever for a period of this length.

With public policy, you can almost never deduce with certainty cause and effect, because everything is too complicated for that. So, we generally have two choices: (1) make policy decisions that are most in line with available data, even though that requires inductive reasoning and some educated guesswork, or (2) make policy decisions that are out of line with available data, because it lines up with our prejudices. I'm arguing for the former option. Conservatives would be cool with that if the data happened to line up with their preferred choice, but since that's almost never the case, they usually are stuck going for the second option.
 
Oneuli said:
I point out the lower rate of increase because that's the relevant metric for figuring out if we're better off with Obamacare than we would have been without it. What you would prefer to do is turn this into a "why I hate Obama" thread. That's the right-wing way. When people are too stupid to talk policy, they talk politicians instead. But the point of this thread was never whether or not the sales pitch for Obamacare was forthright. If you want a thread on that, feel free to start one. The point of this thread is to show how much Obamacare saved Americans.
Click to expand...

And I keep pointing out that Americans were told that healthcare costs would actually go down. They were also told they could keep their doctors. They were also told they could keep their plans.

All of these were lies. Why do you keep pontificating about the lower cost of increase when Obamacare has not lived up to ANY of its promises snowflake?

Obama didn't say Obamacare would reduce the rate of increase; he actually claimed they would go DOWN and that they would LOWER the deficit.

Jonathan Gruber Videos: Oneuli "Too Stupid to Understand" Obamacare
[/QUOTE]
 
Truth Detector said:
I keep pointing out that reducing the rate of cost increase were not the arguments made to sell Obamacare. Why do you continue ignoring those FACTS?

Americans were told that healthcare costs would actually go down. They were also told they could keep their doctors. They were also told they could keep their plans.

All of these were lies. Why do you keep pontificating about the lower cost of increase when Obamacare has not lived up to ANY of its promises snowflake?

Obama didn't say Obamacare would reduce the rate of increase; he actually claimed they would go DOWN and that they would LOWER the deficit.

Jonathan Gruber Videos: Oneuli "Too Stupid to Understand" Obamacare
Click to expand...

Preach it brother!
 
Hefty premium increases are the new normal. Americans who shopped for Obamacare-compliant coverage off the exchanges fared just as poorly as those who watched rates soar on the exchanges. The average individual market plan sold through eHealth, an online insurance marketplace, cost $197 per month in 2013. In 2018, the average plan on eHealth was $440 per month — a 123 percent increase.

1. Health insurance is more expensive than ever.

Remember the promise that the average family would save $2,500 a year on health insurance? Forget about it.

In May 2017 the Department of Health and Human Services reported that average health insurance premiums doubled since 2013. How many families’ incomes doubled over that same period?

In 2018 costs have risen by another 19 percent for high-cost plans and 32 percent for the cheapest plans, according to a study by the Urban Institute. Overall inflation for all other goods and services are running at 2 percent.


4. Americans are paying more money for less health coverage.

According to Kaiser, the average deductible for people with employer-provided health coverage last year was $1,221 compared to $303 in 2006. Usually, you pay higher deductibles for lower premiums. Under Obamacare, you pay more when you get your hospital bill.


https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/commentary/8-reasons-still-hate-obamacare
 
Superfreak said:
Where in that link are you getting the numbers you posted?
Click to expand...

I calculated them. Just take the most recent CPI:medical and calculate the percentage increase from March 2010 (when Obamacare became law). Now calculate the increase for every other period of that length leading up to that date.
 
volsrock said:
Hefty premium increases are the new normal. Americans who shopped for Obamacare-compliant coverage off the exchanges fared just as poorly as those who watched rates soar on the exchanges. The average individual market plan sold through eHealth, an online insurance marketplace, cost $197 per month in 2013. In 2018, the average plan on eHealth was $440 per month — a 123 percent increase.

1. Health insurance is more expensive than ever.

Remember the promise that the average family would save $2,500 a year on health insurance? Forget about it.

In May 2017 the Department of Health and Human Services reported that average health insurance premiums doubled since 2013. How many families’ incomes doubled over that same period?

In 2018 costs have risen by another 19 percent for high-cost plans and 32 percent for the cheapest plans, according to a study by the Urban Institute. Overall inflation for all other goods and services are running at 2 percent.


4. Americans are paying more money for less health coverage.

According to Kaiser, the average deductible for people with employer-provided health coverage last year was $1,221 compared to $303 in 2006. Usually, you pay higher deductibles for lower premiums. Under Obamacare, you pay more when you get your hospital bill.


https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/commentary/8-reasons-still-hate-obamacare
Click to expand...

That's gonna leave a mark on Oneuli's strawman! :laugh:
 
Oneuli said:
I calculated them.
Click to expand...

giphy.gif
 
Truth Detector said:
And I keep pointing out that Americans were told that healthcare costs would actually go down. They were also told they could keep their doctors. They were also told they could keep their plans.

All of these were lies. Why do you keep pontificating about the lower cost of increase when Obamacare has not lived up to ANY of its promises snowflake?

Obama didn't say Obamacare would reduce the rate of increase; he actually claimed they would go DOWN and that they would LOWER the deficit.

Jonathan Gruber Videos: Oneuli "Too Stupid to Understand" Obamacare
Click to expand...

I did get to keep my doctor but that's only because I stayed with BC/BS. I didn't get to keep my plan and my costs did not go down, they went up...a lot.
 
Superfreak said:
https://ldi.upenn.edu/brief/effects-aca-health-care-cost-containment

Try reading this. It is a good read. As it states, due to rising costs, many companies went back to offering high deductible plans. That lowered the growth rate in healthcare costs with the rise in 2013 being just under 3%. After the ACA went into effect in Oct 2013, the growth rate spiked up to 5.3% in 2014 and 5.8% in 2015. So no, the ACA was not a positive on the growth in healthcare costs.
Click to expand...

My data is for the entire period, from Obamacare becoming law through November of 2018. As a simple matter of fact, healthcare inflation over that period was significantly lower than over any period of that length before Obamacare became law. As your link points out, "we have not returned to the double-digit increases of the past" and "to date, evidence has shown health spending has slowed since ACA's passage in 2010." Those authors think more is needed in "the next round of health reform" to bend the cost curve. Fine. But so far, it looks like a big improvement.
 
Truth Detector said:
Deficits didn't lower you brain dead hack. Obama has the record for the largest deficits this nation has ever experienced. I am fairly certain he will retain that title for a very long time.
Click to expand...

What do you think the deficit was when Obama took office? What do you think it was when he left office?
 
Truth Detector said:
And I keep pointing out that Americans were told that healthcare costs would actually go down.
Click to expand...

You see, I keep trying to have a discussion about policy (Obamacare), while you'd prefer to gossip about celebrities (Obama). That's fine. There's a place for that gossip. If you are aroused by pointing out instances of Obama being dishonest, feel free. But it's not the point of this thread. This thread is about how much Obamacare has saved the American people.
 
volsrock said:
Hefty premium increases are the new normal. Americans who shopped for Obamacare-compliant coverage off the exchanges fared just as poorly as those who watched rates soar on the exchanges. The average individual market plan sold through eHealth, an online insurance marketplace, cost $197 per month in 2013. In 2018, the average plan on eHealth was $440 per month — a 123 percent increase.

1. Health insurance is more expensive than ever.

Remember the promise that the average family would save $2,500 a year on health insurance? Forget about it.

In May 2017 the Department of Health and Human Services reported that average health insurance premiums doubled since 2013. How many families’ incomes doubled over that same period?

In 2018 costs have risen by another 19 percent for high-cost plans and 32 percent for the cheapest plans, according to a study by the Urban Institute. Overall inflation for all other goods and services are running at 2 percent.


4. Americans are paying more money for less health coverage.

According to Kaiser, the average deductible for people with employer-provided health coverage last year was $1,221 compared to $303 in 2006. Usually, you pay higher deductibles for lower premiums. Under Obamacare, you pay more when you get your hospital bill.


https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/commentary/8-reasons-still-hate-obamacare
Click to expand...

My post was about overall healthcare costs, not healthcare premiums specifically. Overall costs, obviously, matter more. If I have a choice between, say, a $2,000 premium that leaves me with $10,000 of out-of-pocket medical expenses, or a $5,000 premium that leaves me with $1,000 of out-of-pocket medical expenses, I'd go for the latter, which costs me half as much, even though the premium is five times as large. What matters is my total spend, not how much spending comes under each heading.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top