BREAKING: Trump says he’s going to overturn the 14th Amendment with an executive order.

Uncensored2008 said:
That's the point - they did commit a crime - hence they will be deported.

Did you know that if you murder a bunch of people, then write a book about your crime spree, you are not entitled to the proceeds of the book. Causally called the "Son of Sam" law, this deals with the idea that one cannot profit from the commission of crimes.

Same principle applies here. Criminals deliberately cross the border pregnant in order to profit from the crime.
Click to expand...
These babies born in the United States committed a crime?
 
SYBIL the SILLY SYCHO said:
IMA SILLY SYCHO. WATCH ME DO MY SILLY SYCHO DANCE.
9dapy4.gif
Click to expand...
No thanks, Sybil.
 
Poor Richard Saunders said:
You don't seem to know the difference between persons and citizens.

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Your reading would mean that only citizens born in the US would become citizens. An idiotic reading that no one would accept since it would mean no one could ever be a citizen since they would have to first be a citizen before they became a citizen.
Click to expand...
And subject to the jurisdiction thereof. If your parents are citizens of another country, then they're subject to that country's jurisdiction. If an American is born in most any European country and their parents are not citizens of that country then neither is the child. Many countries do not have birthright citizenship.
 
Jarod said:
I don’t
Click to expand...
Me neither but notice how the MAGA Morons want to shred and rewrite the Constitution in their own image: White, Male and Stupid.

Their latest effort is to replace the Federal Reserve gold with crypto-currency. LOL

Top cryptocurrency executives and investors are pushing President-elect Donald Trump to create a national stockpile of bitcoin, a move that could more closely tie the little-regulated, volatile industry to the future of the country’s finances.

Trump has publicly expressed broad interest in the idea, though some crypto advocates have urged him to take an even more aggressive step: They want him to acquire tokens worth billions of dollars, then hold them for decades in the hopes they will skyrocket in value and help pay down the national debt.
 
Dutch Uncle said:
Me neither but notice how the MAGA Morons want to shred and rewrite the Constitution in their own image: White, Male and Stupid.

Their latest effort is to replace the Federal Reserve gold with crypto-currency. LOL

Top cryptocurrency executives and investors are pushing President-elect Donald Trump to create a national stockpile of bitcoin, a move that could more closely tie the little-regulated, volatile industry to the future of the country’s finances.

Trump has publicly expressed broad interest in the idea, though some crypto advocates have urged him to take an even more aggressive step: They want him to acquire tokens worth billions of dollars, then hold them for decades in the hopes they will skyrocket in value and help pay down the national debt.
Click to expand...
My God, they are stupid.
 
Neil N. Blowme said:
And subject to the jurisdiction thereof. If your parents are citizens of another country, then they're subject to that country's jurisdiction. If an American is born in most any European country and their parents are not citizens of that country then neither is the child. Many countries do not have birthright citizenship.
Click to expand...
You are completely wrong on this count.
If someone is in the US and NOT subject to US jurisdiction then the US can not arrest them, the US can not detain them, the US can not try them in any court, the US can not use any legal system to punish them. When a foreigner is in the US they are subject to the jurisdiction of the US. To not be subject to it would mean any foreigner entering the US could commit crimes and not be punished in any way shape or form. Your argument is ludicrous and completely ignorant of what jurisdiction means. When a foreign diplomat commits a crime, they are not subject to US law. The only recourse the US has is to request that their country remove them.

Every person born in the US is a person. That is what the Constitution says is the requirement to receive citizenship at birth. Unless they are a diplomat they are subject to US laws and therefore under US jurisdiction.

Many countries may not have birthright citizenship, but those countries don't have constitution that states that every person born in that country is a citizen. The only way to end birthright citizenship is to amend the US Constitution.
 
Jarod said:
If you are in the United States, you are subject to its jurisdiction, even if you are a foreigner.
Click to expand...
No, Pretender. They are subject to the jurisdiction of their originating country, UNLESS they legally immigrate AND become citizens of the United States.
Jarod said:
What do you think the word jurisdiction means? You might also be subject to the jurisdiction of your homeland, but for sure you are subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.
Click to expand...
Nope. An illegal immigrant is ILLEGAL, and subject to the jurisdiction of the originating country. That's why they will be deported to there.
You are not a lawyer, Pretender.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top